Explainable Artificial Intelligence: a Systematic Review
–arXiv.org Artificial Intelligence
This has led to the development of a plethora of domain-dependent and context-specific methods for dealing with the interpretation of machine learning (ML) models and the formation of explanations for humans. Unfortunately, this trend is far from being over, with an abundance of knowledge in the field which is scattered and needs organisation. The goal of this article is to systematically review research works in the field of XAI and to try to define some boundaries in the field. From several hundreds of research articles focused on the concept of explainability, about 350 have been considered for review by using the following search methodology. In a first phase, Google Scholar was queried to find papers related to "explainable artificial intelligence", "explainable machine learning" and "interpretable machine learning". Subsequently, the bibliographic section of these articles was thoroughly examined to retrieve further relevant scientific studies. The first noticeable thing, as shown in figure 2 (a), is the distribution of the publication dates of selected research articles: sporadic in the 70s and 80s, receiving preliminary attention in the 90s, showing raising interest in 2000 and becoming a recognised body of knowledge after 2010. The first research concerned the development of an explanation-based system and its integration in a computer program designed to help doctors make diagnoses [3]. Some of the more recent papers focus on work devoted to the clustering of methods for explainability, motivating the need for organising the XAI literature [4, 5, 6].
arXiv.org Artificial Intelligence
Jun-4-2020
- Country:
- Asia
- China > Beijing
- Beijing (0.04)
- Japan
- Honshū > Kantō
- Tokyo Metropolis Prefecture > Tokyo (0.13)
- Kyūshū & Okinawa > Okinawa (0.04)
- Honshū > Kantō
- Macao (0.04)
- Middle East > Republic of Türkiye
- Istanbul Province > Istanbul (0.04)
- Singapore (0.04)
- China > Beijing
- Europe
- Poland > Masovia Province
- Warsaw (0.04)
- Czechia > Prague (0.04)
- United Kingdom
- England
- East Sussex > Brighton (0.04)
- Greater London > London (0.04)
- Scotland > City of Aberdeen
- Aberdeen (0.04)
- England
- Ireland > Leinster
- County Dublin > Dublin (0.14)
- Middle East > Republic of Türkiye
- Istanbul Province > Istanbul (0.04)
- Sweden
- Stockholm > Stockholm (0.04)
- Vaestra Goetaland > Gothenburg (0.04)
- Croatia > Osijek-Baranja County
- Osijek (0.04)
- Norway > Central Norway
- Belgium > Flanders
- West Flanders > Bruges (0.04)
- Italy
- Apulia > Bari (0.04)
- Emilia-Romagna > Metropolitan City of Bologna
- Bologna (0.04)
- Liguria > Genoa (0.04)
- Marche > Ancona Province
- Ancona (0.04)
- Piedmont > Turin Province
- Turin (0.04)
- Trentino-Alto Adige/Südtirol > Trentino Province
- Trento (0.04)
- Tuscany
- Florence (0.04)
- Pisa Province > Pisa (0.04)
- Veneto > Venice (0.04)
- France
- Hauts-de-France > Nord
- Lille (0.04)
- Île-de-France > Paris
- Paris (0.04)
- Hauts-de-France > Nord
- Slovenia (0.04)
- Portugal > Lisbon
- Lisbon (0.04)
- Greece > Attica
- Athens (0.04)
- Denmark > Capital Region
- Copenhagen (0.04)
- Spain
- Andalusia > Cádiz Province
- Cadiz (0.04)
- Canary Islands (0.04)
- Catalonia > Barcelona Province
- Barcelona (0.04)
- Valencian Community > Valencia Province
- Valencia (0.04)
- Andalusia > Cádiz Province
- Germany
- Bavaria > Upper Bavaria
- Munich (0.04)
- Berlin (0.04)
- Bremen > Bremen (0.14)
- Hamburg (0.04)
- North Rhine-Westphalia > Arnsberg Region
- Dortmund (0.04)
- Bavaria > Upper Bavaria
- Netherlands > North Holland
- Amsterdam (0.04)
- Austria > Vienna (0.13)
- Switzerland > Zürich
- Zürich (0.13)
- Poland > Masovia Province
- North America
- Canada
- Alberta
- British Columbia > Metro Vancouver Regional District
- Vancouver (0.14)
- Nova Scotia > Halifax Regional Municipality
- Halifax (0.04)
- Ontario > Toronto (0.04)
- Quebec > Montreal (0.04)
- Mexico > Quintana Roo
- Cancún (0.04)
- Puerto Rico > San Juan
- San Juan (0.04)
- United States
- California
- Los Angeles County
- Long Beach (0.04)
- Los Angeles (0.28)
- Universal City (0.04)
- Orange County > Anaheim (0.04)
- San Diego County > San Diego (0.04)
- San Francisco County > San Francisco (0.28)
- San Mateo County > Menlo Park (0.14)
- Santa Clara County
- Los Angeles County
- Massachusetts
- Middlesex County > Cambridge (0.14)
- Suffolk County > Boston (0.04)
- Alaska > Anchorage Municipality
- Anchorage (0.04)
- District of Columbia > Washington (0.04)
- Michigan > Wayne County
- Detroit (0.04)
- Washington > King County
- Seattle (0.04)
- Georgia > Fulton County
- Atlanta (0.04)
- Virginia (0.04)
- Illinois > Cook County
- Chicago (0.04)
- Utah > Salt Lake County
- Salt Lake City (0.04)
- Pennsylvania > Philadelphia County
- Philadelphia (0.04)
- Louisiana > Orleans Parish
- New Orleans (0.04)
- Rhode Island > Providence County
- Providence (0.04)
- New York
- Bronx County > New York City (0.04)
- Kings County > New York City (0.04)
- New York County > New York City (0.14)
- Queens County > New York City (0.04)
- Richmond County > New York City (0.04)
- Hawaii > Honolulu County
- Honolulu (0.04)
- Texas
- Dallas County > Dallas (0.04)
- Travis County > Austin (0.04)
- Colorado > Denver County
- Denver (0.04)
- Nevada > Clark County
- Las Vegas (0.04)
- Florida
- Miami-Dade County > Miami Beach (0.04)
- Orange County > Orlando (0.04)
- North Carolina > Wake County
- Raleigh (0.04)
- New Jersey > Middlesex County
- New Brunswick (0.04)
- California
- Canada
- Oceania > Australia
- New South Wales > Sydney (0.04)
- Victoria > Melbourne (0.04)
- South America
- Brazil > Rio de Janeiro
- Rio de Janeiro (0.04)
- Chile > Santiago Metropolitan Region
- Santiago Province > Santiago (0.04)
- Brazil > Rio de Janeiro
- Asia
- Genre:
- Overview (1.00)
- Research Report > New Finding (1.00)
- Industry:
- Education > Educational Technology
- Energy (0.67)
- Government > Military (0.67)
- Health & Medicine
- Pharmaceuticals & Biotechnology (0.67)
- Therapeutic Area (1.00)
- Information Technology > Security & Privacy (1.00)
- Law (1.00)
- Leisure & Entertainment (0.67)
- Technology:
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence
- Issues > Social & Ethical Issues (1.00)
- Machine Learning
- Learning Graphical Models > Directed Networks
- Bayesian Learning (1.00)
- Neural Networks > Deep Learning (1.00)
- Performance Analysis > Accuracy (0.67)
- Statistical Learning > Support Vector Machines (0.68)
- Learning Graphical Models > Directed Networks
- Natural Language > Explanation & Argumentation (1.00)
- Representation & Reasoning > Uncertainty
- Bayesian Inference (1.00)
- Fuzzy Logic (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence