Challenging the Myth of Graph Collaborative Filtering: a Reasoned and Reproducibility-driven Analysis

These groundbreaking models are designed to represent users and items as a bipartite, undirected graph, unlocking a whole new level of high-order relationships that were previously almost unattainable. Not only they do achieve better accuracy than their predecessors, but they are also setting a new standard for modern recommender systems [20, 28, 47, 79]. In recent years, great effort has been devoted in creating GNN-based models that address the critical issues of existing models, such as the over-smoothing phenomenon [12] and scalability issues [87]. These cutting-edge models are taking the world of recommender systems by storm and ushering in a new era of accuracy [41, 47, 51, 59, 81]. Over the past ten years, the application of neural techniques rooted in graph representation learning, such as graph convolutional networks [35] (GCNs), has introduced a fresh perspective on traditional collaborative filtering (CF) approaches. Rather than relying solely on user-item interactions for optimization [29, 36, 55], GCN-based methods enable the extraction of both short-and long-distance user preferences toward items [71]. By incorporating multi-hop relationships into the embeddings of users and items, these learned profiles yield more precise recommendations, as evidenced in the literature [28, 47].