UM_FHS at TREC 2024 PLABA: Exploration of Fine-tuning and AI agent approach for plain language adaptations of biomedical text

This paper describes our submissions to the TREC 2024 PLABA track with the aim to simplify biomedical abstracts for a K8 - level audience (13 - 14 years old students). We tested three approaches using OpenAI's gpt - 4o and gpt - 4o - mini models: baseline prompt engineering, a two - AI agent approach, and fine - tuning. Adaptations were evaluated using qualitative metrics ( 5 - point Likert scales for simplicity, accuracy, completeness, and brevity) and quantitative readability scores (Flesch - Kincaid grade level, SMOG Index). Results indicate d that the two - agent approach and baseline prompt engineering with gpt - 4o - mini models show superior qualitative performance, while fine - tuned models excelled in accuracy and completeness but were less simple. The evaluation results demonstrated that prompt engineering with gpt - 4o - mini outperforms iterative improvement strategies via two - agent approach as well as fine - tuning with gpt - 4o. We intend to expand our investigation of the results and explore advanced evaluations.