Agentic AI Frameworks: Architectures, Protocols, and Design Challenges

Aspect Traditional AI agents Modern agentic AI systems (LLM-based agents) Definition Autonomous entities with fixed sensing/acting loops; limited by static rules or models Autonomous reasoning systems using LLMs with dynamic behavior, tool orchestration, and context-awarenessAutonomy Limited autonomy; often dependent on human input or predefined instructions High autonomy; capable of independently performing complex and extended tasks Goal Management Focused on single, static goals or fixed task planning Capable of managing multiple, evolving, and nested goals adaptivelyArchitecture Rule-based or BDI (Belief-Desire-Intention) models; monolithic design Modular architecture centered on LLMs, with components for memory, tools, context injection, and rolesAdaptability Suited to controlled, predictable environments; poor generalization Designed for open, dynamic, and unpredictable environmentsDecision-Making Deterministic or rule-based logic; symbolic reasoning Context-sensitive, probabilistic reasoning with adaptive planning and self-reflection Learning Mechanism Rule-based or supervised learning with limited updates Self-supervised and reinforcement learning; continual fine-tuning possible Context Handling Static or manually coded states and rules Dynamic context injection via agent protocols (e.g., MCP, A2A) and runtime awareness Communication Message-passing via ACL or KQML Real-time, event-driven collaboration; natural language interfacesTool Use Limited or predefined tools and actions Dynamic tool invocation, chaining, and API calling based on contextMemory Optional, often hardcoded or task-specific Integrated memory systems supporting long-and short-term information retention