Model-based versus Model-free Deep Reinforcement Learning for Autonomous Racing Cars

Despite the rich theoretical foundation of model-based deep reinforcement learning (RL) agents, their effectiveness in real-world robotics-applications is less studied and understood. In this paper, we, therefore, investigate how such agents generalize to real-world autonomous-vehicle control-tasks, where advanced model-free deep RL algorithms fail. In particular, we set up a series of time-lap tasks for an F1TENTH racing robot, equipped with high-dimensional LiDAR sensors, on a set of test tracks with a gradual increase in their complexity. In this continuous-control setting, we show that model-based agents capable of learning in imagination, substantially outperform model-free agents with respect to performance, sample efficiency, successful task completion, and generalization. Moreover, we show that the generalization ability of model-based agents strongly depends on the observation-model choice. Finally, we provide extensive empirical evidence for the effectiveness of model-based agents provided with long enough memory horizons in sim2real tasks.