Executable Epistemology: The Structured Cognitive Loop as an Architecture of Intentional Understanding
–arXiv.org Artificial Intelligence
Large language models exhibit intelligence without genuine epistemic understanding, exposing a key gap: the absence of epistemic architecture. This paper introduces the Structured Cognitive Loop (SCL) as an executable epistemological framework for emergent intelligence. Unlike traditional AI research asking "what is intelligence?" (ontological), SCL asks "under what conditions does cognition emerge?" (epistemological). Grounded in philosophy of mind and cognitive phenomenology, SCL bridges conceptual philosophy and implementable cognition. Drawing on process philosophy, enactive cognition, and extended mind theory, we define intelligence not as a property but as a performed process -- a continuous loop of judgment, memory, control, action, and regulation. SCL makes three contributions. First, it operationalizes philosophical insights into computationally interpretable structures, enabling "executable epistemology" -- philosophy as structural experiment. Second, it shows that functional separation within cognitive architecture yields more coherent and interpretable behavior than monolithic prompt based systems, supported by agent evaluations. Third, it redefines intelligence: not representational accuracy but the capacity to reconstruct its own epistemic state through intentional understanding. This framework impacts philosophy of mind, epistemology, and AI. For philosophy, it allows theories of cognition to be enacted and tested. For AI, it grounds behavior in epistemic structure rather than statistical regularity. For epistemology, it frames knowledge not as truth possession but as continuous reconstruction within a phenomenologically coherent loop. We situate SCL within debates on cognitive phenomenology, emergence, normativity, and intentionality, arguing that real progress requires not larger models but architectures that realize cognitive principles structurally.
arXiv.org Artificial Intelligence
Dec-12-2025
- Country:
- Asia > South Korea
- Europe > United Kingdom
- England
- Cambridgeshire > Cambridge (0.04)
- Oxfordshire > Oxford (0.05)
- England
- North America > United States
- California > Santa Clara County
- Palo Alto (0.04)
- Illinois > Cook County
- Chicago (0.04)
- California > Santa Clara County
- Genre:
- Research Report (1.00)
- Industry:
- Health & Medicine > Therapeutic Area > Neurology (0.68)
- Technology:
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence
- Cognitive Science
- Cognitive Architectures (0.48)
- Creativity & Intelligence (0.46)
- Problem Solving (0.46)
- Machine Learning > Neural Networks (0.68)
- Natural Language
- Explanation & Argumentation (0.46)
- Large Language Model (0.69)
- Representation & Reasoning > Rule-Based Reasoning (0.46)
- Cognitive Science
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence