Bayesian Epistemology with Weighted Authority: A Formal Architecture for Truth-Promoting Autonomous Scientific Reasoning
–arXiv.org Artificial Intelligence
The crisis of epistemic overload in modern scientific inquiry has exposed a critical deficiency in how truth claims are assessed, validated, and integrated across time and domain. The exponential growth in peer-reviewed publications, accompanied by inconsistent replication rates, entrenched citation biases, and the sociological entanglements of scientific authorship, has rendered traditional mechanisms of epistemic filtering increasingly obsolete. Simultaneously, artificial intelligence--while having demonstrated capacity in data correlation and language generation--remains fundamentally ill-equipped to perform rigorous epistemic reasoning. This gap is not merely technical but conceptual: current AI systems lack any principled framework for evaluating the truth-promoting value of claims, discerning authoritative sources, or understanding belief as a structured probabilistic relation between agents, claims, and contexts. The present work introduces a formal architecture--Bayesian Epistemology with Weighted Authority (BEW A)--which systematically encodes the logic of belief formation, update, and decay, guided by the core axioms of Bayesian rationality, tempered by structural mechanisms for authority weighting, replication scoring, and temporal reassessment.
arXiv.org Artificial Intelligence
Jun-23-2025
- Country:
- North America > United States (0.45)
- Europe (0.27)
- Genre:
- Research Report > Experimental Study (0.45)
- Industry:
- Information Technology > Security & Privacy (1.00)
- Health & Medicine (1.00)
- Technology:
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence
- Natural Language > Text Processing (1.00)
- Cognitive Science (1.00)
- Representation & Reasoning
- Uncertainty > Bayesian Inference (1.00)
- Scientific Discovery (1.00)
- Logic & Formal Reasoning (1.00)
- Belief Revision (1.00)
- Ontologies (0.68)
- Machine Learning
- Statistical Learning (1.00)
- Neural Networks (0.92)
- Learning Graphical Models > Directed Networks
- Bayesian Learning (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence