In the last decades, energy-based models (EBMs) have become an important class of probabilistic models in which a component of the likelihood is intractable and therefore cannot be evaluated explicitly. Consequently, parameter estimation in EBMs is challenging for conventional inference methods. In this work, we provide a unified framework that connects noise contrastive estimation (NCE), reverse logistic regression (RLR), multiple importance sampling (MIS), and bridge sampling within the context of EBMs. We further show that these methods are equivalent under specific conditions. This unified perspective clarifies relationships among existing methods and enables the development of new estimators, with the potential to improve statistical and computational efficiency. Furthermore, this study helps elucidate the success of NCE in terms of its flexibility and robustness, while also identifying scenarios in which its performance can be further improved. Hence, rather than being a purely descriptive review, this work offers a unifying perspective and additional methodological contributions. The MATLAB code used in the numerical experiments is also made freely available to support the reproducibility of the results.

Wemodel 34], whichisformallyG = hS, U, Pi. S is thestatespacet, every i 2 A {1,..., n} choosesui 2 U which action u 2 U Un. P(s0|s,u): S U S!

We thank all the reviewers for their feedback. All reviewers are concerned whether we substantially outperform QMIX. Since StarCraft II experiments take a long time, we could not include all the results in the submission. Samvelyan et al. have classified as Easy, Hard & Super Hard. Results on several maps are shown below.