1f50893f80d6830d62765ffad7721742-Reviews.html

First provide a summary of the paper, and then address the following criteria: Quality, clarity, originality and significance. Summary: the authors developed a novel method specifically to address an increasingly important problem in neuroscience and cell biology more generally: extract cell bodies from noisy images. The images demonstrate fruitful results, and the quantitative results demonstrate useful performance, although not at the level of a human expert. It would have been nice to see a quantitative comparison between this method and any other previously proposed method. Clarity: i found the paper to be clear.