2) Showed how CANs and the SL follow naturally from introducing constraints into the discriminator of GANs; 3)

Neural Information Processing Systems 

We thank all the reviewers for their careful reviews. None of these follow trivially from Xu et al. In molecule generation, validity is encouraged using the reward-based approach of MolGANs, not the SL. As a result diversity increases (91% to 98.98%) and so does uniqueness (2.4 to 2.5). We will clarify this in the discussion.