Review for NeurIPS paper: Black-Box Ripper: Copying black-box models using generative evolutionary algorithms
–Neural Information Processing Systems
Additional Feedback: The paper can be imporved by including experiments and comparison with baseline on more practical dataset. My main concerns on the dataset and results in many classes have been addressed. Black-box model stealing is also discussed in [1]. Considering previous work[1] in the context, using EA on a pre-trained GAN for model stealing is not so novel. The novelty is limited in using EA in this task.
Neural Information Processing Systems
Feb-7-2025, 15:52:14 GMT