Discussion: Latent variable graphical model selection via convex optimization

By Ming Yuan Georgia Institute of Technology I want to start by congratulating Professors Chandrasekaran, Parrilo and Willsky for this fine piece of work. Their paper, hereafter referred to as CPW, addresses one of the biggest practical challenges of Gaussian graphical models--how to make inferences for a graphical model in the presence of missing variables. The difficulty comes from the fact that the validity of conditional independence relationships implied by a graphical model relies critically on the assumption that all conditional variables are observed, which of course can be unrealistic. As CPW shows, this is not as hopeless as it might appear to be. They characterize conditions under which a conditional graphical model can be identified, and offer a penalized likelihood method to reconstruct it.