Finite-sample risk bounds for maximum likelihood estimation with arbitrary penalties

Remarkably general method for bounding the statistical risk of penalized likelihood estimators comes from work on two-part coding, one of the minimum description length (MDL) approaches to statistical inference. Two-part coding MDL prescribes assigning codelengths to a model (or model class) then selecting the distribution that provides the most efficient description of one's data [1]. The total description length has two parts: the part that specifies a distribution within the model (as well as a model within the model class if necessary) and the part that specifies the data with reference to the specified distribution. If the codelengths are exactly Kraft-valid, this approach is equivalent to Bayesian maximum a posteriori (MAP) estimation, in that the two parts correspond to log reciprocal of prior and log reciprocal of likelihood respectively. More generally, one can call the part of the codelength specifying the distribution a penalty term; it is called the complexity in MDL literature. Let (Θ, L) denote a discrete set indexing distributions along with a complexity function. With X P, the (pointwise) redundancy of any θ Θ is its two-part codelength minus log(1/p(X)), the codelength one gets by using P as the coding distribution.