Uncertainty
Handling missing data in model-based clustering
Serafini, Alessio, Murphy, Thomas Brendan, Scrucca, Luca
Gaussian Mixture models (GMMs) are a powerful tool for clustering, classification and density estimation when clustering structures are embedded in the data. The presence of missing values can largely impact the GMMs estimation process, thus handling missing data turns out to be a crucial point in clustering, classification and density estimation. Several techniques have been developed to impute the missing values before model estimation. Among these, multiple imputation is a simple and useful general approach to handle missing data. In this paper we propose two different methods to fit Gaussian mixtures in the presence of missing data. Both methods use a variant of the Monte Carlo Expectation-Maximisation (MCEM) algorithm for data augmentation. Thus, multiple imputations are performed during the E-step, followed by the standard M-step for a given eigen-decomposed component-covariance matrix. We show that the proposed methods outperform the multiple imputation approach, both in terms of clusters identification and density estimation.
From Probability to Consilience: How Explanatory Values Implement Bayesian Reasoning
Wojtowicz, Zachary, DeDeo, Simon
Recent work in cognitive science has uncovered a diversity of explanatory values, or dimensions along which we judge explanations as better or worse. We propose a Bayesian account of how these values fit together to guide explanation. The resulting taxonomy provides a set of predictors for which explanations people prefer and shows how core values from psychology, statistics, and the philosophy of science emerge from a common mathematical framework. In addition to operationalizing the explanatory virtues associated with, for example, scientific argument-making, this framework also enables us to reinterpret the explanatory vices that drive conspiracy theories, delusions, and extremist ideologies. Intuitively, philosophically, and as seen in laboratory experiments, explanations are judged as better or worse on the basis of many different criteria. These explanatory values appear in early childhood [1, 2, 3, 4, 5] and their influence extends to some of the most sophisticated social knowledge formation processes we know [6]. We lack, however, an understanding of the origin of these values or an account of how they fit together to guide belief formation. The multiplicity of values also appears to conflict with Bayesian models of cognition, which speak solely in terms of degrees of beliefs and suggest we judge explanations as better or worse on the basis of a single quantity, the posterior likelihood (see Glossary). In this opinion, we show how to resolve these conflicts by arguing that previously-identified explanatory values capture different components of a full Bayesian calculation and, when considered together and weighed appropriately, implement Bayesian cognition. This framework shows how key explanatory values identified by laboratory experiments and philosophers of science--co-explanation, descriptiveness, precision, unification, power, and simplicity--emerge naturally from the mathematical structure of probabilistic inference, thereby reconciling them with Bayesian models of cognition [7, 8]. Second, it shows how these values combine to produce preferences for one explanation over another.
Explaining The Behavior Of Black-Box Prediction Algorithms With Causal Learning
Sani, Numair, Malinsky, Daniel, Shpitser, Ilya
We propose to explain the behavior of black-box prediction methods (e.g., deep neural networks trained on image pixel data) using causal graphical models. Specifically, we explore learning the structure of a causal graph where the nodes represent prediction outcomes along with a set of macro-level "interpretable" features, while allowing for arbitrary unmeasured confounding among these variables. The resulting graph may indicate which of the interpretable features, if any, are possible causes of the prediction outcome and which may be merely associated with prediction outcomes due to confounding. The approach is motivated by a counterfactual theory of causal explanation wherein good explanations point to factors which are "difference-makers" in an interventionist sense. The resulting analysis may be useful in algorithm auditing and evaluation, by identifying features which make a causal difference to the algorithm's output.
Bayesian optimization for modular black-box systems with switching costs
Lin, Chi-Heng, Miano, Joseph D., Dyer, Eva L.
Most existing black-box optimization methods assume that all variables in the system being optimized have equal cost and can change freely at each iteration. However, in many real world systems, inputs are passed through a sequence of different operations or modules, making variables in earlier stages of processing more costly to update. Such structure imposes a cost on switching variables in early parts of a data processing pipeline. In this work, we propose a new algorithm for switch cost-aware optimization called Lazy Modular Bayesian Optimization (LaMBO). This method efficiently identifies the global optimum while minimizing cost through a passive change of variables in early modules. The method is theoretical grounded and achieves vanishing regret when augmented with switching cost. We apply LaMBO to multiple synthetic functions and a three-stage image segmentation pipeline used in a neuroscience application, where we obtain promising improvements over prevailing cost-aware Bayesian optimization algorithms. Our results demonstrate that LaMBO is an effective strategy for black-box optimization that is capable of minimizing switching costs in modular systems.
Double Generative Adversarial Networks for Conditional Independence Testing
Shi, Chengchun, Xu, Tianlin, Bergsma, Wicher, Li, Lexin
In this article, we consider the problem of high-dimensional conditional independence testing, which is a key building block in statistics and machine learning. We propose a double generative adversarial networks (GANs)-based inference procedure. We first introduce a double GANs framework to learn two generators, and integrate the two generators to construct a doubly-robust test statistic. We next consider multiple generalized covariance measures, and take their maximum as our test statistic. Finally, we obtain the empirical distribution of our test statistic through multiplier bootstrap. We show that our test controls type-I error, while the power approaches one asymptotically. More importantly, these theoretical guarantees are obtained under much weaker and practically more feasible conditions compared to existing tests. We demonstrate the efficacy of our test through both synthetic and real datasets.
Prediction of short and long-term droughts using artificial neural networks and hydro-meteorological variables
Hassanzadeh, Yousef, Ghazvinian, Mohammadvaghef, Abdi, Amin, Baharvand, Saman, Jozaghi, Ali
Drought is a natural creeping threat with numerous damaging effects in various aspects of human life. Accurate drought prediction is a promising step in helping policy makers to set drought risk management strategies. To fulfill this purpose, choosing appropriate models plays an important role in predicting approach. In this study, different models of Artificial Neural Network (ANN) are employed to predict short and long-term of droughts by using Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI) at different time scales, including 3, 6, 12, 24 and 48 months in Tabriz city, Iran. To this end, different combination of calculated SPI and time series of various hydro-meteorological variables, such as precipitation, wind velocity, relative humidity and sunshine hours for years 1992 to 2010 are used to train the ANN models. In order to compare the models performances, some well-known measures, namely RMSE, Mean Absolute Error (MAE) and Correlation Coefficient (CC) are utilized in the present study. The results illustrate that the application of all hydro-meteorological variables significantly improves the prediction of SPI at different time scales.
Shallow Neural Hawkes: Non-parametric kernel estimation for Hawkes processes
Joseph, Sobin, Kashyap, Lekhapriya Dheeraj, Jain, Shashi
Multi-dimensional Hawkes process (MHP) is a class of self and mutually exciting point processes that find wide range of applications -- from prediction of earthquakes to modelling of order books in high frequency trading. This paper makes two major contributions, we first find an unbiased estimator for the log-likelihood estimator of the Hawkes process to enable efficient use of the stochastic gradient descent method for maximum likelihood estimation. The second contribution is, we propose a specific single hidden layered neural network for the non-parametric estimation of the underlying kernels of the MHP. We evaluate the proposed model on both synthetic and real datasets, and find the method has comparable or better performance than existing estimation methods. The use of shallow neural network ensures that we do not compromise on the interpretability of the Hawkes model, while at the same time have the flexibility to estimate any non-standard Hawkes excitation kernel.
You say Normalizing Flows I see Bayesian Networks
Wehenkel, Antoine, Louppe, Gilles
Normalizing flows have emerged as an important family of deep neural networks for modelling complex probability distributions. In this note, we revisit their coupling and autoregressive transformation layers as probabilistic graphical models and show that they reduce to Bayesian networks with a pre-defined topology and a learnable density at each node. From this new perspective, we provide three results. First, we show that stacking multiple transformations in a normalizing flow relaxes independence assumptions and entangles the model distribution. Second, we show that a fundamental leap of capacity emerges when the depth of affine flows exceeds 3 transformation layers. Third, we prove the non-universality of the affine normalizing flow, regardless of its depth.
Adaptive quadrature schemes for Bayesian inference via active learning
Llorente, F., Martino, L., Elvira, V., Delgado, D., López-Santiago, J.
Numerical integration and emulation are fundamental topics across scientific fields. We propose novel adaptive quadrature schemes based on an active learning procedure. We consider an interpolative approach for building a surrogate posterior density, combining it with Monte Carlo sampling methods and other quadrature rules. The nodes of the quadrature are sequentially chosen by maximizing a suitable acquisition function, which takes into account the current approximation of the posterior and the positions of the nodes. This maximization does not require additional evaluations of the true posterior. We introduce two specific schemes based on Gaussian and Nearest Neighbors (NN) bases. For the Gaussian case, we also provide a novel procedure for fitting the bandwidth parameter, in order to build a suitable emulator of a density function. With both techniques, we always obtain a positive estimation of the marginal likelihood (a.k.a., Bayesian evidence). An equivalent importance sampling interpretation is also described, which allows the design of extended schemes. Several theoretical results are provided and discussed. Numerical results show the advantage of the proposed approach, including a challenging inference problem in an astronomic dynamical model, with the goal of revealing the number of planets orbiting a star.
Kernel Taylor-Based Value Function Approximation for Continuous-State Markov Decision Processes
Xu, Junhong, Yin, Kai, Liu, Lantao
We propose a principled kernel-based policy iteration algorithm to solve the continuous-state Markov Decision Processes (MDPs). In contrast to most decision-theoretic planning frameworks, which assume fully known state transition models, we design a method that eliminates such a strong assumption, which is oftentimes extremely difficult to engineer in reality. To achieve this, we first apply the second-order Taylor expansion of the value function. The Bellman optimality equation is then approximated by a partial differential equation, which only relies on the first and second moments of the transition model. By combining the kernel representation of value function, we then design an efficient policy iteration algorithm whose policy evaluation step can be represented as a linear system of equations characterized by a finite set of supporting states. We have validated the proposed method through extensive simulations in both simplified and realistic planning scenarios, and the experiments show that our proposed approach leads to a much superior performance over several baseline methods.