Uncertainty
Predicting Seminal Quality with the Dominance-Based Rough Sets Approach
The paper relies on the clinical data of a previously published study. We identify two very questionable assumptions of said work, namely confusing evidence of absence and absence of evidence, and neglecting the ordinal nature of attributes' domains. We then show that using an adequate ordinal methodology such as the dominance-based rough sets approach (DRSA) can significantly improve the predictive accuracy of the expert system, resulting in almost complete accuracy for a dataset of 100 instances. Beyond the performance of DRSA in solving the diagnosis problem at hand, these results suggest the inadequacy and triviality of the underlying dataset. We provide links to open data from the UCI machine learning repository to allow for an easy verification/refutation of the claims made in this paper. Keywords: Decision Support Systems, Expert Systems, Dominance Based Rough Set Approach, Diagnosis, Seminal Quality.
Bayesian prognostic covariate adjustment
Walsh, David, Schuler, Alejandro, Hall, Diana, Walsh, Jon, Fisher, Charles
Historical data about disease outcomes can be integrated into the analysis of clinical trials in many ways. We build on existing literature that uses prognostic scores from a predictive model to increase the efficiency of treatment effect estimates via covariate adjustment. Here we go further, utilizing a Bayesian framework that combines prognostic covariate adjustment with an empirical prior distribution learned from the predictive performances of the prognostic model on past trials. The Bayesian approach interpolates between prognostic covariate adjustment with strict type I error control when the prior is diffuse, and a single-arm trial when the prior is sharply peaked. This method is shown theoretically to offer a substantial increase in statistical power, while limiting the type I error rate under reasonable conditions. We demonstrate the utility of our method in simulations and with an analysis of a past Alzheimer's disease clinical trial.
AutonoML: Towards an Integrated Framework for Autonomous Machine Learning
Kedziora, David Jacob, Musial, Katarzyna, Gabrys, Bogdan
Over the last decade, the long-running endeavour to automate high-level processes in machine learning (ML) has risen to mainstream prominence, stimulated by advances in optimisation techniques and their impact on selecting ML models/algorithms. Central to this drive is the appeal of engineering a computational system that both discovers and deploys high-performance solutions to arbitrary ML problems with minimal human interaction. Beyond this, an even loftier goal is the pursuit of autonomy, which describes the capability of the system to independently adjust an ML solution over a lifetime of changing contexts. However, these ambitions are unlikely to be achieved in a robust manner without the broader synthesis of various mechanisms and theoretical frameworks, which, at the present time, remain scattered across numerous research threads. Accordingly, this review seeks to motivate a more expansive perspective on what constitutes an automated/autonomous ML system, alongside consideration of how best to consolidate those elements. In doing so, we survey developments in the following research areas: hyperparameter optimisation, multi-component models, neural architecture search, automated feature engineering, meta-learning, multi-level ensembling, dynamic adaptation, multi-objective evaluation, resource constraints, flexible user involvement, and the principles of generalisation. We also develop a conceptual framework throughout the review, augmented by each topic, to illustrate one possible way of fusing high-level mechanisms into an autonomous ML system. Ultimately, we conclude that the notion of architectural integration deserves more discussion, without which the field of automated ML risks stifling both its technical advantages and general uptake.
A Comparative Study of AHP and Fuzzy AHP Method for Inconsistent Data
Ashek-Al-Aziz, Md., Mahmud, Sagar, Islam, Md. Azizul, Mahmud, Jubayer Al, Hasib, Khan Md.
In various cases of decision analysis we use two popular methods: Analytical Hierarchical Process (AHP) and Fuzzy based AHP or Fuzzy AHP. Both the methods deal with stochastic data and can determine decision result through Multi Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) process. Obviously resulting values of the two methods are not same though same set of data is fed into them. In this research work, we have tried to observe similarities and dissimilarities between two methods outputs. Almost same trend or fluctuations in outputs have been seen for both methods for same set of input data which are not consistent. Both method outputs ups and down fluctuations are same for fifty percent cases.
High-Dimensional Bayesian Optimization via Tree-Structured Additive Models
Han, Eric, Arora, Ishank, Scarlett, Jonathan
Bayesian Optimization (BO) has shown significant success in tackling expensive low-dimensional black-box optimization problems. Many optimization problems of interest are high-dimensional, and scaling BO to such settings remains an important challenge. In this paper, we consider generalized additive models in which low-dimensional functions with overlapping subsets of variables are composed to model a high-dimensional target function. Our goal is to lower the computational resources required and facilitate faster model learning by reducing the model complexity while retaining the sample-efficiency of existing methods. Specifically, we constrain the underlying dependency graphs to tree structures in order to facilitate both the structure learning and optimization of the acquisition function. For the former, we propose a hybrid graph learning algorithm based on Gibbs sampling and mutation. In addition, we propose a novel zooming-based algorithm that permits generalized additive models to be employed more efficiently in the case of continuous domains. We demonstrate and discuss the efficacy of our approach via a range of experiments on synthetic functions and real-world datasets.
Learning Structures in Earth Observation Data with Gaussian Processes
Mateo, Fernando, Munoz-Mari, Jordi, Laparra, Valero, Verrelst, Jochem, Camps-Valls, Gustau
Gaussian Processes (GPs) has experienced tremendous success in geoscience in general and for bio-geophysical parameter retrieval in the last years. GPs constitute a solid Bayesian framework to formulate many function approximation problems consistently. This paper reviews the main theoretical GP developments in the field. We review new algorithms that respect the signal and noise characteristics, that provide feature rankings automatically, and that allow applicability of associated uncertainty intervals to transport GP models in space and time. All these developments are illustrated in the field of geoscience and remote sensing at a local and global scales through a set of illustrative examples.
Evolutionary Variational Optimization of Generative Models
Drefs, Jakob, Guiraud, Enrico, Lรผcke, Jรถrg
We combine two popular optimization approaches to derive learning algorithms for generative models: variational optimization and evolutionary algorithms. The combination is realized for generative models with discrete latents by using truncated posteriors as the family of variational distributions. The variational parameters of truncated posteriors are sets of latent states. By interpreting these states as genomes of individuals and by using the variational lower bound to define a fitness, we can apply evolutionary algorithms to realize the variational loop. The used variational distributions are very flexible and we show that evolutionary algorithms can effectively and efficiently optimize the variational bound. Furthermore, the variational loop is generally applicable ("black box") with no analytical derivations required. To show general applicability, we apply the approach to three generative models (we use noisy-OR Bayes Nets, Binary Sparse Coding, and Spike-and-Slab Sparse Coding). To demonstrate effectiveness and efficiency of the novel variational approach, we use the standard competitive benchmarks of image denoising and inpainting. The benchmarks allow quantitative comparisons to a wide range of methods including probabilistic approaches, deep deterministic and generative networks, and non-local image processing methods. In the category of "zero-shot" learning (when only the corrupted image is used for training), we observed the evolutionary variational algorithm to significantly improve the state-of-the-art in many benchmark settings. For one well-known inpainting benchmark, we also observed state-of-the-art performance across all categories of algorithms although we only train on the corrupted image. In general, our investigations highlight the importance of research on optimization methods for generative models to achieve performance improvements.
Hardware-accelerated Simulation-based Inference of Stochastic Epidemiology Models for COVID-19
Kulkarni, Sourabh, Krell, Mario Michael, Nabarro, Seth, Moritz, Csaba Andras
Epidemiology models are central in understanding and controlling large scale pandemics. Several epidemiology models require simulation-based inference such as Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC) to fit their parameters to observations. ABC inference is highly amenable to efficient hardware acceleration. In this work, we develop parallel ABC inference of a stochastic epidemiology model for COVID-19. The statistical inference framework is implemented and compared on Intel Xeon CPU, NVIDIA Tesla V100 GPU and the Graphcore Mk1 IPU, and the results are discussed in the context of their computational architectures. Results show that GPUs are 4x and IPUs are 30x faster than Xeon CPUs. Extensive performance analysis indicates that the difference between IPU and GPU can be attributed to higher communication bandwidth, closeness of memory to compute, and higher compute power in the IPU. The proposed framework scales across 16 IPUs, with scaling overhead not exceeding 8% for the experiments performed. We present an example of our framework in practice, performing inference on the epidemiology model across three countries, and giving a brief overview of the results.
Empirical Bayes PCA in high dimensions
Zhong, Xinyi, Su, Chang, Fan, Zhou
When the dimension of data is comparable to or larger than the number of available data samples, Principal Components Analysis (PCA) is known to exhibit problematic phenomena of high-dimensional noise. In this work, we propose an Empirical Bayes PCA method that reduces this noise by estimating a structural prior for the joint distributions of the principal components. This EB-PCA method is based upon the classical Kiefer-Wolfowitz nonparametric MLE for empirical Bayes estimation, distributional results derived from random matrix theory for the sample PCs, and iterative refinement using an Approximate Message Passing (AMP) algorithm. In theoretical "spiked" models, EB-PCA achieves Bayes-optimal estimation accuracy in the same settings as the oracle Bayes AMP procedure that knows the true priors. Empirically, EB-PCA can substantially improve over PCA when there is strong prior structure, both in simulation and on several quantitative benchmarks constructed using data from the 1000 Genomes Project and the International HapMap Project. A final illustration is presented for an analysis of gene expression data obtained by single-cell RNA-seq.
Fast Physical Activity Suggestions: Efficient Hyperparameter Learning in Mobile Health
Menictas, Marianne, Tomkins, Sabina, Murphy, Susan
Users can be supported to adopt healthy behaviors, such as regular physical activity, via relevant and timely suggestions on their mobile devices. Recently, reinforcement learning algorithms have been found to be effective for learning the optimal context under which to provide suggestions. However, these algorithms are not necessarily designed for the constraints posed by mobile health (mHealth) settings, that they be efficient, domain-informed and computationally affordable. We propose an algorithm for providing physical activity suggestions in mHealth settings. Using domain-science, we formulate a contextual bandit algorithm which makes use of a linear mixed effects model. We then introduce a procedure to efficiently perform hyper-parameter updating, using far less computational resources than competing approaches. Not only is our approach computationally efficient, it is also easily implemented with closed form matrix algebraic updates and we show improvements over state of the art approaches both in speed and accuracy of up to 99% and 56% respectively.