Uncertainty
Causal Discovery with Generalized Linear Models through Peeling Algorithms
Wang, Minjie, Shen, Xiaotong, Pan, Wei
This article presents a novel method for causal discovery with generalized structural equation models suited for analyzing diverse types of outcomes, including discrete, continuous, and mixed data. Causal discovery often faces challenges due to unmeasured confounders that hinder the identification of causal relationships. The proposed approach addresses this issue by developing two peeling algorithms (bottom-up and top-down) to ascertain causal relationships and valid instruments. This approach first reconstructs a super-graph to represent ancestral relationships between variables, using a peeling algorithm based on nodewise GLM regressions that exploit relationships between primary and instrumental variables. Then, it estimates parent-child effects from the ancestral relationships using another peeling algorithm while deconfounding a child's model with information borrowed from its parents' models. The article offers a theoretical analysis of the proposed approach, which establishes conditions for model identifiability and provides statistical guarantees for accurately discovering parent-child relationships via the peeling algorithms. Furthermore, the article presents numerical experiments showcasing the effectiveness of our approach in comparison to state-of-the-art structure learning methods without confounders. Lastly, it demonstrates an application to Alzheimer's disease (AD), highlighting the utility of the method in constructing gene-to-gene and gene-to-disease regulatory networks involving Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs) for healthy and AD subjects.
Cyclic Directed Probabilistic Graphical Model: A Proposal Based on Structured Outcomes
In the process of building (structural learning) a probabilistic graphical model from a set of observed data, the directional, cyclic dependencies between the random variables of the model are often found. Existing graphical models such as Bayesian and Markov networks can reflect such dependencies. However, this requires complicating those models, such as adding additional variables or dividing the model graph into separate subgraphs. Herein, we describe a probabilistic graphical model - probabilistic relation network - that allows the direct capture of directional cyclic dependencies during structural learning. This model is based on the simple idea that each sample of the observed data can be represented by an arbitrary graph (structured outcome), which reflects the structure of the dependencies of the variables included in the sample. Each of the outcomes contains only a part of the graphical model structure; however, a complete graph of the probabilistic model is obtained by combining different outcomes. Such a graph, unlike Bayesian and Markov networks, can be directed and can have cycles. We explored the full joint distribution and conditional distribution and conditional independence properties of variables in the proposed model. We defined the algorithms for constructing of the model from the dataset and for calculating the conditional and full joint distributions. We also performed a numerical comparison with Bayesian and Markov networks. This model does not violate the probability axioms, and it supports learning from observed data. Notably, it supports probabilistic inference, making it a prospective tool in data analysis and in expert and design-making applications.
Local Discovery by Partitioning: Polynomial-Time Causal Discovery Around Exposure-Outcome Pairs
Maasch, Jacqueline, Pan, Weishen, Gupta, Shantanu, Kuleshov, Volodymyr, Gan, Kyra, Wang, Fei
This work addresses the problem of automated covariate selection under limited prior knowledge. Given an exposure-outcome pair {X,Y} and a variable set Z of unknown causal structure, the Local Discovery by Partitioning (LDP) algorithm partitions Z into subsets defined by their relation to {X,Y}. We enumerate eight exhaustive and mutually exclusive partitions of any arbitrary Z and leverage this taxonomy to differentiate confounders from other variable types. LDP is motivated by valid adjustment set identification, but avoids the pretreatment assumption commonly made by automated covariate selection methods. We provide theoretical guarantees that LDP returns a valid adjustment set for any Z that meets sufficient graphical conditions. Under stronger conditions, we prove that partition labels are asymptotically correct. Total independence tests is worst-case quadratic in |Z|, with sub-quadratic runtimes observed empirically. We numerically validate our theoretical guarantees on synthetic and semi-synthetic graphs. Adjustment sets from LDP yield less biased and more precise average treatment effect estimates than baselines, with LDP outperforming on confounder recall, test count, and runtime for valid adjustment set discovery.
Efficient Neural Network Approaches for Conditional Optimal Transport with Applications in Bayesian Inference
Wang, Zheyu Oliver, Baptista, Ricardo, Marzouk, Youssef, Ruthotto, Lars, Verma, Deepanshu
Both approaches enable sampling and density estimation of conditional probability distributions, which are core tasks in Bayesian inference. Our methods represent the target conditional distributions as transformations of a tractable reference distribution and, therefore, fall into the framework of measure transport. COT maps are a canonical choice within this framework, with desirable properties such as uniqueness and monotonicity. However, the associated COT problems are computationally challenging, even in moderate dimensions. To improve the scalability, our numerical algorithms leverage neural networks to parameterize COT maps. Our methods exploit the structure of the static and dynamic formulations of the COT problem. PCP-Map models conditional transport maps as the gradient of a partially input convex neural network (PICNN) and uses a novel numerical implementation to increase computational efficiency compared to state-of-the-art alternatives. COT-Flow models conditional transports via the flow of a regularized neural ODE; it is slower to train but offers faster sampling. We demonstrate their effectiveness and efficiency by comparing them with state-of-the-art approaches using benchmark datasets and Bayesian inverse problems.
A Mean Field Approach to Empirical Bayes Estimation in High-dimensional Linear Regression
Mukherjee, Sumit, Sen, Bodhisattva, Sen, Subhabrata
We study empirical Bayes estimation in high-dimensional linear regression. To facilitate computationally efficient estimation of the underlying prior, we adopt a variational empirical Bayes approach, introduced originally in Carbonetto and Stephens (2012) and Kim et al. (2022). We establish asymptotic consistency of the nonparametric maximum likelihood estimator (NPMLE) and its (computable) naive mean field variational surrogate under mild assumptions on the design and the prior. Assuming, in addition, that the naive mean field approximation has a dominant optimizer, we develop a computationally efficient approximation to the oracle posterior distribution, and establish its accuracy under the 1-Wasserstein metric. This enables computationally feasible Bayesian inference; e.g., construction of posterior credible intervals with an average coverage guarantee, Bayes optimal estimation for the regression coefficients, estimation of the proportion of non-nulls, etc. Our analysis covers both deterministic and random designs, and accommodates correlations among the features. To the best of our knowledge, this provides the first rigorous nonparametric empirical Bayes method in a high-dimensional regression setting without sparsity.
Squared Neural Families: A New Class of Tractable Density Models
Tsuchida, Russell, Ong, Cheng Soon, Sejdinovic, Dino
Flexible models for probability distributions are an essential ingredient in many machine learning tasks. We develop and investigate a new class of probability distributions, which we call a Squared Neural Family (SNEFY), formed by squaring the 2-norm of a neural network and normalising it with respect to a base measure. Following the reasoning similar to the well established connections between infinitely wide neural networks and Gaussian processes, we show that SNEFYs admit closed form normalising constants in many cases of interest, thereby resulting in flexible yet fully tractable density models. SNEFYs strictly generalise classical exponential families, are closed under conditioning, and have tractable marginal distributions. Their utility is illustrated on a variety of density estimation, conditional density estimation, and density estimation with missing data tasks.
Cause-Effect Inference in Location-Scale Noise Models: Maximum Likelihood vs. Independence Testing
A fundamental problem of causal discovery is cause-effect inference, learning the correct causal direction between two random variables. Significant progress has been made through modelling the effect as a function of its cause and a noise term, which allows us to leverage assumptions about the generating function class. The recently introduced heteroscedastic location-scale noise functional models (LSNMs) combine expressive power with identifiability guarantees. LSNM model selection based on maximizing likelihood achieves state-of-the-art accuracy, when the noise distributions are correctly specified. However, through an extensive empirical evaluation, we demonstrate that the accuracy deteriorates sharply when the form of the noise distribution is misspecified by the user. Our analysis shows that the failure occurs mainly when the conditional variance in the anti-causal direction is smaller than that in the causal direction. As an alternative, we find that causal model selection through residual independence testing is much more robust to noise misspecification and misleading conditional variance.
Adaptive importance sampling for heavy-tailed distributions via $\alpha$-divergence minimization
Guilmeau, Thomas, Branchini, Nicola, Chouzenoux, Emilie, Elvira, Víctor
Adaptive importance sampling (AIS) algorithms are widely used to approximate expectations with respect to complicated target probability distributions. When the target has heavy tails, existing AIS algorithms can provide inconsistent estimators or exhibit slow convergence, as they often neglect the target's tail behaviour. To avoid this pitfall, we propose an AIS algorithm that approximates the target by Student-t proposal distributions. We adapt location and scale parameters by matching the escort moments - which are defined even for heavy-tailed distributions - of the target and the proposal. These updates minimize the $\alpha$-divergence between the target and the proposal, thereby connecting with variational inference. We then show that the $\alpha$-divergence can be approximated by a generalized notion of effective sample size and leverage this new perspective to adapt the tail parameter with Bayesian optimization. We demonstrate the efficacy of our approach through applications to synthetic targets and a Bayesian Student-t regression task on a real example with clinical trial data.
Free-form Flows: Make Any Architecture a Normalizing Flow
Draxler, Felix, Sorrenson, Peter, Zimmermann, Lea, Rousselot, Armand, Köthe, Ullrich
Normalizing Flows are generative models that directly maximize the likelihood. Previously, the design of normalizing flows was largely constrained by the need for analytical invertibility. We overcome this constraint by a training procedure that uses an efficient estimator for the gradient of the change of variables formula. This enables any dimension-preserving neural network to serve as a generative model through maximum likelihood training. Our approach allows placing the emphasis on tailoring inductive biases precisely to the task at hand. Specifically, we achieve excellent results in molecule generation benchmarks utilizing $E(n)$-equivariant networks. Moreover, our method is competitive in an inverse problem benchmark, while employing off-the-shelf ResNet architectures.
Joint Distributional Learning via Cramer-Wold Distance
An, Seunghwan, Jeon, Jong-June
The assumption of conditional independence among observed variables, primarily used in the Variational Autoencoder (VAE) decoder modeling, has limitations when dealing with high-dimensional datasets or complex correlation structures among observed variables. To address this issue, we introduced the Cramer-Wold distance regularization, which can be computed in a closed-form, to facilitate joint distributional learning for high-dimensional datasets. Additionally, we introduced a two-step learning method to enable flexible prior modeling and improve the alignment between the aggregated posterior and the prior distribution. Furthermore, we provide theoretical distinctions from existing methods within this category. To evaluate the synthetic data generation performance of our proposed approach, we conducted experiments on high-dimensional datasets with multiple categorical variables. Given that many readily available datasets and data science applications involve such datasets, our experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed methodology.