Ontologies
On the Undecidability of Fuzzy Description Logics with GCIs with Lukasiewicz t-norm
Cerami, Marco, Straccia, Umberto
Recently there have been some unexpected results concerning Fuzzy Description Logics (FDLs) with General Concept Inclusions (GCIs). They show that, unlike the classical case, the DL ALC with GCIs does not have the finite model property under Lukasiewicz Logic or Product Logic and, specifically, knowledge base satisfiability is an undecidable problem for Product Logic. We complete here the analysis by showing that knowledge base satisfiability is also an undecidable problem for Lukasiewicz Logic.
Query strategy for sequential ontology debugging
Shchekotykhin, Kostyantyn, Friedrich, Gerhard, Fleiss, Philipp, Rodler, Patrick
Debugging of ontologies is an important prerequisite for their wide-spread application, especially in areas that rely upon everyday users to create and maintain knowledge bases, as in the case of the Semantic Web. Recent approaches use diagnosis methods to identify causes of inconsistent or incoherent ontologies. However, in most debugging scenarios these methods return many alternative diagnoses, thus placing the burden of fault localization on the user. This paper demonstrates how the target diagnosis can be identified by performing a sequence of observations, that is, by querying an oracle about entailments of the target ontology. We exploit a-priori probabilities of typical user errors to formulate information-theoretic concepts for query selection. Our evaluation showed that the proposed method significantly reduces the number of required queries compared to myopic strategies. We experimented with different probability distributions of user errors and different qualities of the a-priori probabilities. Our measurements showed the advantageousness of information-theoretic approach to query selection even in cases where only a rough estimate of the priors is available.
Beth Definability in Expressive Description Logics
Cate, Balder ten (University of California, Santa Cruz) | Franconi, Enrico (Free University of Bozen-Bolzano) | Seylan, İnanç (Free University of Bozen-Bolzano)
The Beth definability property, a well-known property from classical logic, is investigated in the context of description logics (DLs): if a general L-TBox implicitly defines an L-concept in terms of a given signature, where L is a DL, then does there always exist over this signature an explicit definition in L for the concept? This property has been studied before and used to optimize reasoning in DLs. In this paper a complete classification of Beth definability is provided for extensions of the basic DL ALC with transitive roles, inverse roles, role hierarchies, and/or functionality restrictions, both on arbitrary and on finite structures. Moreover, we present a tableau-based algorithm which computes explicit definitions of at most double exponential size. This algorithm is optimal because it is also shown that the smallest explicit definition of an implicitly defined concept may be double exponentially long in the size of the input TBox. Finally, if explicit definitions are allowed to be expressed in first-order logic then we show how to compute them in EXPTIME.
Efficient Rule-Based Inferencing for OWL EL
Krötzsch, Markus (University of Oxford)
We review recent results on inferencing for SROEL(×), a description logic that subsumes the main features of the W3C recommendation OWL EL. Rule-based deduction systems are developed for various reasoning tasks and logical sublanguages. Certain feature combinations lead to increased space upper bounds for materialisation, suggesting that efficient implementations are easier to obtain for suitable fragments of OWL EL.
Autonomous Object Manipulation: A Semantic-Driven Approach
Vitucci, Nicola (Politecnico di Milano)
The problem of grasping is widely studied in the The problem of semantic part decomposition is still an robotics community. This project focuses on the open problem and, to the best of our knowledge, there are identification of object graspable features using images no tools available to automatically create a fuzzy ontology and object structural information. The primary from raw data taken from an image. The use of fuzzy DLs for aim is the creation of a framework in which the information object recognition has been investigated in some works such gathered by the vision system can be integrated as [Hudelot et al., 2008], in which little advantage is taken with automatically generated knowledge, from the (partial) fuzzy extension and from the expressivity modelled by means of fuzzy description logics. of the used logic (i.e., no cardinality restrictions are used); furthermore, a preliminary phase of semantic annotation of the images by domain experts has to be performed.
Log-Linear Description Logics
Niepert, Mathias (University of Mannheim) | Noessner, Jan (University of Mannheim) | Stuckenschmidt, Heiner (University of Mannheim)
Log-linear description logics are a family of probabilistic logics integrating various concepts and methods from the areas of knowledge representation and reasoning and statistical relational AI. We define the syntax and semantics of log-linear description logics, describe a convenient representation as sets of first-order formulas, and discuss computational and algorithmic aspects of probabilistic queries in the language. The paper concludes with an experimental evaluation of an implementation of a log-linear DL reasoner.
A Method for Evaluating and Standardizing Ontologies
Seyed, Ali Patrice (University at Buffalo)
For my thesis work I am developing a method for evaluating and standardizing ontologies based on an integration of the Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) and OntoClean. BFO serves as the upper ontology for the domain ontologies of the Open Biomedical Ontologies (OBO) Foundry. The OBO Foundry initiative is a collaborative effort for developing interoperable, science-based ontologies. OntoClean is an approach for the quality assurance of ontologies, and helps a modeler detect when the subsumption relation is used improperly. Ontologies developed for OBO use include some that have been ratified, and others holding the status of “candidate”. To maintain consistency between ontologies, it is important to establish formal principled criteria that a candidate ontology must meet for ratification. The formalisms that result from our integration will serve as criteria an OBO Foundry candidate ontology must satisfy in order to be ratified. The formalisms will also serve as a constraints within a prototype of an ontology editor that interactively asks a modeler questions that helps alleviate constraint violations.
RDFKB: A Semantic Web Knowledge Base
McGlothlin, James P. (The University of Texas at Dallas) | Khan, Latifur (The University of Texas at Dallas) | Thuraisingham, Bhavani (The University of Texas at Dallas)
There are many significant research projects focused on providing semantic web repositories that are scalable and efficient. However, the true value of the semantic web architecture is its ability to represent meaningful knowledge and not just data. Therefore, a semantic web knowledge base should do more than retrieve collections of triples. We propose RDFKB (Resource Description Knowledge Base), a complete semantic web knowledge case. RDFKB is a solution for managing, persisting and querying semantic web knowledge. Our experiments with real world and synthetic datasets demonstrate that RDFKB achieves superior query performance to other state-of-the-art solutions. The key features of RDFKB that differentiate it from other solutions are: 1) a simple and efficient process for data additions, deletions and updates that does not involve reprocessing the dataset; 2) materialization of inferred triples at addition time without performance degradation; 3) materialization of uncertain information and support for queries involving probabilities; 4) distributed inference across datasets; 5) ability to apply alignments to the dataset and perform queries against multiple sources using alignment. RDFKB allows more knowledge to be stored and retrieved; it is a repository not just for RDF datasets, but also for inferred triples, probability information, and lineage information. RDFKB provides a complete and efficient RDF data repository and knowledge base.
An On-Line Algorithm for Semantic Forgetting
Packer, Heather Stephanie (University of Southampton) | Gibbins, Nicholas (University of Southampton) | Jennings, Nicholas R (University of Southampton)
In AI, this area Ontologies that evolve through use to support new has been studied under a variety of names such as forgetting domain tasks can grow extremely large. Moreover, and variable elimination [Eiter et al., 2006; Wang et al., large ontologies require more resources to use and 2008]. We provide a general approach for ranking knowledge have slower response times than small ones. To according to its use and cost, which can be applied to systems help address this problem, we present an online semantic that are limited by memory resources to evaluate memory forgetting algorithm that removes ontology allocation. We also provide a specific approach to select fragments containing infrequently used or cheap to which concepts to remove from an ontology, using the ranking.
The Combined Approach to Ontology-Based Data Access
Kontchakov, Roman (Birkbeck College London) | Lutz, Carsten (University of Bremen) | Toman, David (University of Waterloo) | Wolter, Frank (University of Liverpool) | Zakharyaschev, Michael (Birkbeck College London)
The use of ontologies for accessing data is one of the most exciting new applications of description logic in databases and other information systems. A realistic way of realising sufficiently scalable ontology- based data access in practice is by reduction to querying relational databases. In this paper, we describe the ‘combined approach,’ which incorporates the information given by the ontology into the data and employs query rewriting to eliminate spurious answers. We illustrate this approach for ontologies given in the DL-Lite family of description logics and briefly discuss the results obtained for the EL family.