Ontologies
Computing Horn Rewritings of Description Logics Ontologies
Kaminski, Mark (University of Oxford) | Grau, Bernardo Cuenca (University of Oxford)
We study the problem of rewriting an ontology O1 expressed in a DL L1 into an ontology O2 in a Horn DL L2 such that O1 and O2 are equisatisfiable when extended with an arbitrary dataset. Ontologies that admit such rewritings are amenable to reasoning techniques ensuring tractability in data complexity. After showing undecidability whenever L1 extends ALCF , we focus on devising efficiently checkable conditions that ensure existence of a Horn rewriting. By lifting existing techniques for rewriting Disjunctive Datalog programs into plain Datalog to the case of arbitrary first-order programs with function symbols, we identify a class of ontologies that admit Horn rewritings of polynomial size. Our experiments indicate that many real-world ontologies satisfy our sufficient conditions and thus admit polynomial Horn rewritings.
Schema.org as a Description Logic
Hernich, Andre (University of Liverpool) | Lutz, Carsten (University of Bremen) | Ozaki, Ana (University of Liverpool) | Wolter, Frank (University of Liverpool)
Schema.org is an initiative by the major search engine providers Bing, Google, Yahoo, and Yandex that provides a collection of ontologies which webmasters can use to mark up their pages. Schema.org comes without a formal language definition and without a clear semantics. We formalize the language of Schema.org as a Description Logic (DL) and study the complexity of querying data using (unions of) conjunctive queries in the presence of ontologies formulated in this DL (from several perspectives). While querying is intractable in general, we identify various cases in which it is tractable and where queries are even rewritable into FO queries or datalog programs.
Efficient Query Rewriting in the Description Logic EL and Beyond
Hansen, Peter (University of Bremen) | Lutz, Carsten (University of Bremen) | Seylan, İnanç (University of Bremen) | Wolter, Frank (University of Liverpool)
We propose a new type of algorithm for computing first-order (FO) rewritings of concept queries under ELHdr-TBoxes. The algorithm is tailored towards efficient implementation, yet complete. It outputs a succinct non-recursive datalog rewriting if the input is FO-rewritable and otherwise reports non-FO-rewritability. We carry out experiments with real-world ontologies which demonstrate excellent performance in practice and show that TBoxes originating from applications admit FO-rewritings of reasonable size in almost all cases, even when in theory such rewritings are not guaranteed to exist.
Polynomial Rewritings for Linear Existential Rules
Gottlob, Georg (University of Oxford) | Manna, Marco (University of Calabria) | Pieris, Andreas (Vienna University of Technology)
We consider the scenario of ontology-based query answering. It is generally accepted that true scalability in this setting can only be achieved via query rewriting, which in turn allows for the exploitation of standard RDBMSs. In this work, we close two open fundamental questions related to query rewriting. We establish that linear existential rules are polynomially combined rewritable, while full linear rules are polynomially (purely) rewritable; in both cases, the target query language consists of first-order or non-recursive Datalog queries. An immediate consequence of our results is that DLR-Lite_R, the extension of DL-Lite_R with n-ary roles, is polynomially combined rewritable.
The Combined Approach to Query Answering Beyond the OWL 2 Profiles
Feier, Cristina (University of Oxford) | Carral, David (Wright State University) | Stefanoni, Giorgio (University of Oxford) | Grau, Bernardo Cuenca (University of Oxford) | Horrocks, Ian (University of Oxford)
Combined approaches have become a successful technique for CQ answering over ontologies. Existing algorithms, however, are restricted to the logics underpinning the OWL 2 profiles. Our goal is to make combined approaches applicable to a wider range of ontologies. We focus on RSA: a class of Horn ontologies that extends the profiles while ensuring tractability of standard reasoning. We show that CQ answering over RSA ontologies without role composition is feasible in NP. Our reasoning procedure generalises the combined approach for ELHO and DL-LiteR using an encoding of CQ answering into fact entailment w.r.t. a logic program with function symbols and stratified negation. Our results have significant practical implications since many out-of-profile Horn ontologies are RSA.
Controlled Query Evaluation for Datalog and OWL 2 Profile Ontologies
Grau, Bernardo Cuenca (University of Oxford) | Kharlamov, Evgeny (University of Oxford) | Kostylev, Egor V. (University of Oxford) | Zheleznyakov, Dmitriy (University of Oxford)
We study confidentiality enforcement in ontologies under the Controlled Query Evaluation framework, where a policy specifies the sensitive information and a censor ensures that query answers that may compromise the policy are not returned. We focus on censors that ensure confidentiality while maximising information access, and consider both Datalog and the OWL 2 profiles as ontology languages.
On the Undecidability of the Situation Calculus Extended with Description Logic Ontologies
Calvanese, Diego (Free University of Bozen-Bolzano Bolzano) | Giacomo, Giuseppe De (Sapienza Universita') | Soutchanski, Mikhail (di Roma)
In this paper we investigate situation calculus action theories extended with ontologies, expressed as description logics TBoxes that act as state constraints. We show that this combination, while natural and desirable, is particularly problematic: it leads to undecidability of the simplest form of reasoning, namely satisfiability, even for the simplest kinds of description logics and the simplest kind of situation calculus action theories.
Reasonable Highly Expressive Query Languages
Bourhis, Pierre (CNRS CRIStAL UMR 9189) | Krötzsch, Markus (TU Dresden) | Rudolph, Sebastian (TU Dresden)
Expressive query languages are gaining relevance in knowledge representation (KR), and new reasoning problems come to the fore. Especially query containment is interesting in this context. The problem is known to be decidable for many expressive query languages, but exact complexities are often missing. We introduce a new query language, guarded queries (GQ), which generalizes most known languages where query containment is decidable. GQs can be nested (more expressive), or restricted to linear recursion (less expressive). Our comprehensive analysis of the computational properties and expressiveness of (linear/nested) GQs also yields insights on many previous languages.
Temporal Query Answering in the Description Logic EL
Borgwardt, Stefan (Technische Universität Dresden) | Thost, Veronika (Technische Universität Dresden)
Context-aware systems use data collected at runtime to recognize certain predefined situations and trigger adaptations. This can be implemented using ontology-based data access (OBDA), which augments classical query answering in databases by adopting the open-world assumption and including domain knowledge provided by an ontology. We investigate temporalized OBDA w.r.t. ontologies formulated in EL, a description logic that allows for efficient reasoning and is successfully used in practice. We consider a recently proposed temporalized query language that combines conjunctive queries with the operators of propositional linear temporal logic (LTL), and study both data and combined complexity of query entailment in this setting. We also analyze the satisfiability problem in the similar formalism EL-LTL.
The Complexity of Subsumption in Fuzzy EL
Borgwardt, Stefan (Technische Universität Dresden) | Cerami, Marco (Palacký University in Olomouc) | Peñaloza, Rafael (Free University of Bozen-Bolzano)
Fuzzy Description Logics (DLs) are used to represent and reason about vague and imprecise knowledge that is inherent to many application domains. It was recently shown that the complexity of reasoning in finitely valued fuzzy DLs is often not higher than that of the underlying classical DL. We show that this does not hold for fuzzy extensions of the light-weight DL EL, which is used in many biomedical ontologies, under the Lukasiewicz semantics. The complexity of reasoning increases from PTime to ExpTime, even if only one additional truth value is introduced. The same lower bound holds also for infinitely valued Lukasiewicz extensions of EL.