tunability
On the Tunability of Random Survival Forests Model for Predictive Maintenance
Yardımcı, Yigitcan, Cavus, Mustafa
This paper investigates the tunability of the Random Survival Forest (RSF) model in predictive maintenance, where accurate time-to-failure estimation is crucial. Although RSF is widely used due to its flexibility and ability to handle censored data, its performance is sensitive to hyperparameter configurations. However, systematic evaluations of RSF tunability remain limited, especially in predictive maintenance contexts. We introduce a three-level framework to quantify tunability: (1) a model-level metric measuring overall performance gain from tuning, (2) a hyperparameter-level metric assessing individual contributions, and (3) identification of optimal tuning ranges. These metrics are evaluated across multiple datasets using survival-specific criteria: the C-index for discrimination and the Brier score for calibration. Experiments on four CMAPSS dataset subsets, simulating aircraft engine degradation, reveal that hyperparameter tuning consistently improves model performance. On average, the C-index increased by 0.0547, while the Brier score decreased by 0.0199. These gains were consistent across all subsets. Moreover, ntree and mtry showed the highest average tunability, while nodesize offered stable improvements within the range of 10 to 30. In contrast, splitrule demonstrated negative tunability on average, indicating that improper tuning may reduce model performance. Our findings emphasize the practical importance of hyperparameter tuning in survival models and provide actionable insights for optimizing RSF in real-world predictive maintenance applications.
The Role of Hyperparameters in Predictive Multiplicity
Cavus, Mustafa, Woźnica, Katarzyna, Biecek, Przemysław
This paper investigates the critical role of hyperparameters in predictive multiplicity, where different machine learning models trained on the same dataset yield divergent predictions for identical inputs. These inconsistencies can seriously impact high-stakes decisions such as credit assessments, hiring, and medical diagnoses. Focusing on six widely used models for tabular data - Elastic Net, Decision Tree, k-Nearest Neighbor, Support Vector Machine, Random Forests, and Extreme Gradient Boosting - we explore how hyperparameter tuning influences predictive multiplicity, as expressed by the distribution of prediction discrepancies across benchmark datasets. Key hyperparameters such as lambda in Elastic Net, gamma in Support Vector Machines, and alpha in Extreme Gradient Boosting play a crucial role in shaping predictive multiplicity, often compromising the stability of predictions within specific algorithms. Our experiments on 21 benchmark datasets reveal that tuning these hyperparameters leads to notable performance improvements but also increases prediction discrepancies, with Extreme Gradient Boosting exhibiting the highest discrepancy and substantial prediction instability. This highlights the trade-off between performance optimization and prediction consistency, raising concerns about the risk of arbitrary predictions. These findings provide insight into how hyperparameter optimization leads to predictive multiplicity. While predictive multiplicity allows prioritizing domain-specific objectives such as fairness and reduces reliance on a single model, it also complicates decision-making, potentially leading to arbitrary or unjustified outcomes.
HyperSHAP: Shapley Values and Interactions for Hyperparameter Importance
Wever, Marcel, Muschalik, Maximilian, Fumagalli, Fabian, Lindauer, Marius
Hyperparameter optimization (HPO) is a crucial step in achieving strong predictive performance. However, the impact of individual hyperparameters on model generalization is highly context-dependent, prohibiting a one-size-fits-all solution and requiring opaque automated machine learning (AutoML) systems to find optimal configurations. The black-box nature of most AutoML systems undermines user trust and discourages adoption. To address this, we propose a game-theoretic explainability framework for HPO that is based on Shapley values and interactions. Our approach provides an additive decomposition of a performance measure across hyperparameters, enabling local and global explanations of hyperparameter importance and interactions. The framework, named HyperSHAP, offers insights into ablations, the tunability of learning algorithms, and optimizer behavior across different hyperparameter spaces. We evaluate HyperSHAP on various HPO benchmarks by analyzing the interaction structure of the HPO problem. Our results show that while higher-order interactions exist, most performance improvements can be explained by focusing on lower-order representations.
Self-deployable contracting-cord metamaterials with tunable mechanical properties
Yan, Wenzhong, Jones, Talmage, Jawetz, Christopher L., Lee, Ryan H., Hopkins, Jonathan B., Mehta, Ankur
Recent advances in active materials and fabrication techniques have enabled the production of cyclically self-deployable metamaterials with an expanded functionality space. However, designing metamaterials that possess continuously tunable mechanical properties after self-deployment remains a challenge, notwithstanding its importance. Inspired by push puppets, we introduce an efficient design strategy to create reversibly self-deployable metamaterials with continuously tunable post-deployment stiffness and damping. Our metamaterial comprises contracting actuators threaded through beads with matching conical concavo-convex interfaces in networked chains. The slack network conforms to arbitrary shapes, but when actuated, it self-assembles into a preprogrammed configuration with beads gathered together. Further contraction of the actuators can dynamically tune the assembly's mechanical properties through the beads' particle jamming, while maintaining the overall structure with minimal change. We show that, after deployment, such metamaterials exhibit pronounced tunability in bending-dominated configurations: they can become more than 35 times stiffer and change their damping capability by over 50%. Through systematic analysis, we find that the beads'conical angle can introduce geometric nonlinearity, which has a major effect on the self-deployability and tunability of the metamaterial. Our work provides routes towards reversibly self-deployable, lightweight, and tunable metamaterials, with potential applications in soft robotics, reconfigurable architectures, and space engineering.
On the Tunability of Optimizers in Deep Learning
Sivaprasad, Prabhu Teja, Mai, Florian, Vogels, Thijs, Jaggi, Martin, Fleuret, François
There is no consensus yet on the question whether adaptive gradient methods like Adam are easier to use than non-adaptive optimization methods like SGD. In this work, we fill in the important, yet ambiguous concept of `ease-of-use' by defining an optimizer's \emph{tunability}: How easy is it to find good hyperparameter configurations using automatic random hyperparameter search? We propose a practical and universal quantitative measure for optimizer tunability that can form the basis for a fair optimizer benchmark. Evaluating a variety of optimizers on an extensive set of standard datasets and architectures, we find that Adam is the most tunable for the majority of problems, especially with a low budget for hyperparameter tuning.
TG-PSM: Tunable Greedy Packet Sequence Morphing Based on Trace Clustering
Common privacy enhancing technologies fail to effectively hide certain statistical aspects of encrypted traffic, namely individual packets length, packets direction and, packets timing. Recent researches have shown that using such attributes, an adversary is able to extract various information from the encrypted traffic such as the visited website and used protocol. Such attacks are called traffic analysis. Proposed countermeasures attempt to change the distribution of such features. however, either they fail to effectively reduce attacker's accuracy or do so while enforcing high bandwidth overhead and timing delay. In this paper, through the use of a predefined set of clustered traces of websites and a greedy packet morphing algorithm, we introduce a website fingerprinting countermeasure called TG-PSM. Firstly, this method clusters websites based on their behavior in different phases of loading. Secondly, it finds a suitable target site for any visiting website based on user indicated importance degree; thus providing dynamic tunability. Thirdly, this method morphs the given website to the target website using a greedy algorithm considering the distance and the resulted overhead. Our evaluations show that TG-PSM outperforms previous countermeasures regarding attacker accuracy reduction and enforced bandwidth, e.g., reducing bandwidth overhead over 40% while maintaining attacker's accuracy.
Tunability: Importance of Hyperparameters of Machine Learning Algorithms
Probst, Philipp, Bischl, Bernd, Boulesteix, Anne-Laure
Modern machine learning algorithms for classification or regression such as gradient boosting, random forest and neural networks involve a number of parameters that have to be fixed before running them. Such parameters are commonly denoted as hyperparameters in machine learning, a terminology we also adopt here. The term tuning parameter is also frequently used to denote parameters that should be carefully tuned, i.e. optimized with respect to performance. The users of these algorithms can use defaults of these hyperparameters that are specified in the employed software package, set them to alternative specific values or use a tuning strategy to choose them appropriately for the specific dataset at hand. In this context, we define tunability as the amount of performance gain that can be achieved by setting the considered hyperparameter to the best possible value instead of the default value. The goal of this paper is two-fold. Firstly, we formalize the problem of tuning from a statistical point of view and suggest general measures quantifying the tunability of hyperparameters of algorithms. Secondly, we conduct a large-scale benchmarking study based on 38 datasets from the OpenML platform (Vanschoren et al., 2013) using six of the most common machine learning algorithms for classification and regression and apply our measures to assess the tunability of their parameters. The results yield interesting insights into the investigated hyperparameters that in some cases allow general conclusions on their tunability. Our results may help users of the algorithms to decide whether it is worth to conduct a possibly time consuming tuning strategy, to focus on the most important hyperparameters and to chose adequate hyperparameter spaces for tuning.