reviewer
Group Fairness in Peer Review
Large conferences such as NeurIPS and AAAI serve as crossroads of various AI fields, since they attract submissions from a vast number of communities. However, in some cases, this has resulted in a poor reviewing experience for some communities, whose submissions get assigned to less qualified reviewers outside of their communities. An often-advocated solution is to break up any such large conference into smaller conferences, but this can lead to isolation of communities and harm interdisciplinary research.
- North America > Canada > Ontario > Toronto (0.15)
- Europe > Switzerland > Zürich > Zürich (0.04)
- North America > United States > Pennsylvania > Allegheny County > Pittsburgh (0.04)
- North America > Canada > Ontario > Toronto (0.04)
- North America > United States > California > Santa Clara County > Palo Alto (0.04)
- Research Report > New Finding (1.00)
- Research Report > Experimental Study (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Representation & Reasoning > Optimization (0.46)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Representation & Reasoning > Personal Assistant Systems (0.46)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning > Statistical Learning (0.46)
We would like to thank the reviewers for their constructive feedbacks and we will correct the typos raised and include
Full (exact) conformal set vs. split or cross-validated conformal set Non-connectedness of the conformal prediction set. This was initially suggested in [18, Remark 1]. We follow the actual practice in the literature [14, Remark 5]. We did not observe violations. We will also summarize the proposed algorithm in a direct pseudo-code.
704cddc91e28d1a5517518b2f12bc321-AuthorFeedback.pdf
We thank the reviewers for their feedback. We will first respond to shared and then to individual comments. Additionally, reviewers 2 and 3 requested clarification regarding the advantages of DCA over other methods. For instance, one could attempt to correlate each neuron's contribution to the DCA subspace with single-neuron Studying the behavior of Kernel DCA is a direction for future studies. Additionally, we found and corrected a minor bug in Figure 1A: the SFA and DCA lines are now blue and red, respectively.
- North America > United States > Pennsylvania > Allegheny County > Pittsburgh (0.04)
- North America > Canada > Ontario > Toronto (0.04)
- North America > Canada > British Columbia > Metro Vancouver Regional District > Vancouver (0.04)