bnb-adopt
BnB-ADOPT: An Asynchronous Branch-and-Bound DCOP Algorithm
Yeoh, William, Felner, Ariel, Koenig, Sven
Distributed constraint optimization (DCOP) problems are a popular way of formulating and solving agent-coordination problems. A DCOP problem is a problem where several agents coordinate their values such that the sum of the resulting constraint costs is minimal. It is often desirable to solve DCOP problems with memory-bounded and asynchronous algorithms. We introduce Branch-and-Bound ADOPT (BnB-ADOPT), a memory-bounded asynchronous DCOP search algorithm that uses the message-passing and communication framework of ADOPT (Modi, Shen, Tambe, and Yokoo, 2005), a well known memory-bounded asynchronous DCOP search algorithm, but changes the search strategy of ADOPT from best-first search to depth-first branch-and-bound search. Our experimental results show that BnB-ADOPT finds cost-minimal solutions up to one order of magnitude faster than ADOPT for a variety of large DCOP problems and is as fast as NCBB, a memory-bounded synchronous DCOP search algorithm, for most of these DCOP problems. Additionally, it is often desirable to find bounded-error solutions for DCOP problems within a reasonable amount of time since finding cost-minimal solutions is NP-hard. The existing bounded-error approximation mechanism allows users only to specify an absolute error bound on the solution cost but a relative error bound is often more intuitive. Thus, we present two new bounded-error approximation mechanisms that allow for relative error bounds and implement them on top of BnB-ADOPT.
- North America > United States > California > Los Angeles County > Los Angeles (0.28)
- Europe > United Kingdom > England > Cambridgeshire > Cambridge (0.04)
- Asia > Middle East > Israel > Southern District > Beer-Sheva (0.04)
Generalizing ADOPT and BnB-ADOPT
Gutierrez, Patricia (IIIA-CSIC, Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona) | Meseguer, Pedro (IIIA-CSIC, Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona) | Yeoh, William (University of Massachusetts)
ADOPT and BnB-ADOPT are two optimal DCOP search algorithms that are similar except for their search strategies: the former uses best-first search and the latter uses depth-first branch-and-bound search. In this paper, we present a new algorithm, called ADOPT( k ), that generalizes them. Its behavior depends on the k parameter. It behaves like ADOPT when k = 1, like BnB-ADOPT when k = ∞ and like a hybrid of ADOPT and BnB-ADOPT when 1 < k < ∞. We prove that ADOPT( k ) is a correct and complete algorithm and experimentally show that ADOPT( k ) outperforms ADOPT and BnB-ADOPT on several benchmarks across several metrics.
- North America > United States > Massachusetts > Hampshire County > Amherst (0.14)
- Europe > Spain (0.04)
Distributed Constraint Optimization Problems Related with Soft Arc Consistency
Gutierrez, Patricia (IIIA-CSIC, Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona) | Meseguer, Pedro (IIIA-CSIC, Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona)
Distributed Constraint Optimization Problems (DCOPs) can be optimally solved by distributed search algorithms, such as ADOPT and BnB-ADOPT. In centralized solving, maintaining soft arc consistency during search has proved to be beneficial for performance. In this thesis we aim to explore the maintenance of different levels of soft arc consistency in distributed search when solving DCOPs.
Saving Redundant Messages in BnB-ADOPT
Gutierrez, Patricia (Spanish National Research Council) | Meseguer, Pedro (Spanish National Research Council)
A message msg sent from i to j reference algorithm for distributed constraint optimization is redundant if at some future time t, the collective effect of (DCOP), defined as follows. There is a finite number of other messages arriving j between msg and t would cause agents, each holding one variable that can take values from a the same effect, so msg could have been avoided.
BnB-ADOPT: An Asynchronous Branch-and-Bound DCOP Algorithm
Yeoh, W., Felner, A., Koenig, S.
Distributed constraint optimization (DCOP) problems are a popular way of formulating and solving agent-coordination problems. A DCOP problem is a problem where several agents coordinate their values such that the sum of the resulting constraint costs is minimal. It is often desirable to solve DCOP problems with memory-bounded and asynchronous algorithms. We introduce Branch-and-Bound ADOPT (BnB-ADOPT), a memory-bounded asynchronous DCOP search algorithm that uses the message-passing and communication framework of ADOPT (Modi, Shen, Tambe, & Yokoo, 2005), a well known memory-bounded asynchronous DCOP search algorithm, but changes the search strategy of ADOPT from best-first search to depth-first branch-and-bound search. Our experimental results show that BnB-ADOPT finds cost-minimal solutions up to one order of magnitude faster than ADOPT for a variety of large DCOP problems and is as fast as NCBB, a memory-bounded synchronous DCOP search algorithm, for most of these DCOP problems. Additionally, it is often desirable to find bounded-error solutions for DCOP problems within a reasonable amount of time since finding cost-minimal solutions is NP-hard. The existing bounded-error approximation mechanism allows users only to specify an absolute error bound on the solution cost but a relative error bound is often more intuitive. Thus, we present two new bounded-error approximation mechanisms that allow for relative error bounds and implement them on top of BnB-ADOPT.
- North America > United States > California > Los Angeles County > Los Angeles (0.28)
- Europe > United Kingdom > England > Cambridgeshire > Cambridge (0.04)
- Asia > Middle East > Israel > Southern District > Beer-Sheva (0.04)
Trading Off Solution Quality for Faster Computation in DCOP Search Algorithms
Yeoh, William (University of Southern California) | Sun, Xiaoxun (University of Southern California) | Koenig, Sven (University of Southern California)
Distributed Constraint Optimization (DCOP) is a key technique for solving agent coordination problems. Because finding cost-minimal DCOP solutions is NP-hard, it is important to develop mechanisms for DCOP search algorithms that trade off their solution costs for smaller runtimes. However, existing tradeoff mechanisms do not provide relative error bounds. In this paper, we introduce three tradeoff mechanisms that provide such bounds, namely the Relative Error Mechanism, the Uniformly Weighted Heuristics Mechanism and the Non-Uniformly Weighted Heuristics Mechanism, for two DCOP algorithms, namely ADOPT and BnB-ADOPT. Our experimental results show that the Relative Error Mechanism generally dominates the other two tradeoff mechanisms for ADOPT and the Uniformly Weighted Heuristics Mechanism generally dominates the other two tradeoff mechanisms for BnB-ADOPT.