Advancing AI Research and Applications by Learning from What Went Wrong and Why

This special issue of AI Magazine is dedicated to the proposition that problems populate the path to insight, implying the experiences and lessons learned should be shared.

This was a large applied research effort that presented many opportunities for unusual experiences. In one such experience, I was called in, at the last minute, to help improve our ALV proposal. The proposal was a 300-page document that segued smoothly from problem description to corporate capabilities and managerial plan, omitting any mention of technical approach. This taught me a rule of thumb I have seen validated many times: the larger the project (in dollars and scope), the poorer the technical proposal. In a second experience, I was demonstrating a dynamic programming algorithm at a quarterly review.