Selker, Ted
Generative AI's aggregated knowledge versus web-based curated knowledge
Selker, Ted, Wu, Yunzi
his paper explores what kinds of questions are best served by the way generative AI (GenAI) using Large Language Models(LLMs) that aggregate and package knowledge, and when traditional curated web-sourced search results serve users better. An experiment compared product searches using ChatGPT, Google search engine, or both helped us understand more about the compelling nature of generated responses. The experiment showed GenAI can speed up some explorations and decisions. We describe how search can deepen the testing of facts, logic, and context. We show where existing and emerging knowledge paradigms can help knowledge exploration in different ways. Experimenting with searches, our probes showed the value for curated web search provides for very specific, less popularly-known knowledge. GenAI excelled at bringing together knowledge for broad, relatively well-known topics. The value of curated and aggregated knowledge for different kinds of knowledge reflected in different user goals. We developed a taxonomy to distinguishing when users are best served by these two approaches.
AI for the Generation and Testing of Ideas Towards an AI Supported Knowledge Development Environment
Selker, Ted
New systems employ Machine Learning to sift through large knowledge sources, creating flexible Large Language Models. These models discern context and predict sequential information in various communication forms. Generative AI, leveraging Transformers, generates textual or visual outputs mimicking human responses. It proposes one or multiple contextually feasible solutions for a user to contemplate. However, generative AI does not currently support traceability of ideas, a useful feature provided by search engines indicating origin of information. The narrative style of generative AI has gained positive reception. People learn from stories. Yet, early ChatGPT efforts had difficulty with truth, reference, calculations, and aspects like accurate maps. Current capabilities of referencing locations and linking to apps seem to be better catered by the link-centric search methods we've used for two decades. Deploying truly believable solutions extends beyond simulating contextual relevance as done by generative AI. Combining the creativity of generative AI with the provenance of internet sources in hybrid scenarios could enhance internet usage. Generative AI, viewed as drafts, stimulates thinking, offering alternative ideas for final versions or actions. Scenarios for information requests are considered. We discuss how generative AI can boost idea generation by eliminating human bias. We also describe how search can verify facts, logic, and context. The user evaluates these generated ideas for selection and usage. This paper introduces a system for knowledge workers, Generate And Search Test, enabling individuals to efficiently create solutions previously requiring top collaborations of experts.
An Adaptive Mediating Agent for Teleconferences
Rajan, Rahul (Carnegie Mellon University) | Selker, Ted (University of California, Berkeley)
Conference calls represent a natural but limited communication channel between people. Lack of visual contact and limited bandwidth impoverish social cues people typically use to moderate their behavior. This paper presents a system capable of providing timely aural feedback enabling meeting participants to check themselves. The system is able to sense and recognize problems, reason about them, and make decisions on how and when to provide feedback based on an interaction policy. While a hand-crafted policy based on expert insight can be used, it is non-optimal and can be brittle. Instead, we use reinforcement learning to build a system that can adapt to users by interacting with them. To evaluate the system, we first conduct a user study and demonstrate its utility in getting meeting participants to contribute more equally. We then validate the adaptive feedback policy by demonstrating the agent's ability to adapt its action choices to different types of users.
Reports of the AAAI 2011 Conference Workshops
Agmon, Noa (University of Texas at Austin) | Agrawal, Vikas (Infosys Labs) | Aha, David W. (Naval Research Laboratory) | Aloimonos, Yiannis (University of Maryland, College Park) | Buckley, Donagh (EMC) | Doshi, Prashant (University of Georgia) | Geib, Christopher (University of Edinburgh) | Grasso, Floriana (University of Liverpool) | Green, Nancy (University of North Carolina Greensboro) | Johnston, Benjamin (University of Technology, Sydney) | Kaliski, Burt (VeriSign, Inc.) | Kiekintveld, Christopher (University of Texas at El Paso) | Law, Edith (Carnegie Mellon University) | Lieberman, Henry (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) | Mengshoel, Ole J. (Carnegie Mellon University) | Metzler, Ted (Oklahoma City University) | Modayil, Joseph (University of Alberta) | Oard, Douglas W. (University of Maryland, College Park) | Onder, Nilufer (Michigan Technological University) | O'Sullivan, Barry (University College Cork) | Pastra, Katerina (Cognitive Systems Research Insitute) | Precup, Doina (McGill University) | Ramachandran, Sowmya (Stottler Henke Associates, Inc.) | Reed, Chris (University of Dundee) | Sariel-Talay, Sanem (Istanbul Technical University) | Selker, Ted (Carnegie Mellon University) | Shastri, Lokendra (Infosys Technologies Ltd.) | Smith, Stephen F. (Carnegie Mellon University) | Singh, Satinder (University of Michigan at Ann Arbor) | Srivastava, Siddharth (University of Wisconsin, Madison) | Sukthankar, Gita (University of Central Florida) | Uthus, David C. (Naval Research Laboratory) | Williams, Mary-Anne (University of Technology, Sydney)
The AAAI-11 workshop program was held Sunday and Monday, August 7–18, 2011, at the Hyatt Regency San Francisco in San Francisco, California USA. The AAAI-11 workshop program included 15 workshops covering a wide range of topics in artificial intelligence. The titles of the workshops were Activity Context Representation: Techniques and Languages; Analyzing Microtext; Applied Adversarial Reasoning and Risk Modeling; Artificial Intelligence and Smarter Living: The Conquest of Complexity; AI for Data Center Management and Cloud Computing; Automated Action Planning for Autonomous Mobile Robots; Computational Models of Natural Argument; Generalized Planning; Human Computation; Human-Robot Interaction in Elder Care; Interactive Decision Theory and Game Theory; Language-Action Tools for Cognitive Artificial Agents: Integrating Vision, Action and Language; Lifelong Learning; Plan, Activity, and Intent Recognition; and Scalable Integration of Analytics and Visualization. This article presents short summaries of those events.
Reports of the AAAI 2011 Conference Workshops
Agmon, Noa (University of Texas at Austin) | Agrawal, Vikas (Infosys Labs) | Aha, David W. (Naval Research Laboratory) | Aloimonos, Yiannis (University of Maryland, College Park) | Buckley, Donagh (EMC) | Doshi, Prashant (University of Georgia) | Geib, Christopher (University of Edinburgh) | Grasso, Floriana (University of Liverpool) | Green, Nancy (University of North Carolina Greensboro) | Johnston, Benjamin (University of Technology, Sydney) | Kaliski, Burt (VeriSign, Inc.) | Kiekintveld, Christopher (University of Texas at El Paso) | Law, Edith (Carnegie Mellon University) | Lieberman, Henry (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) | Mengshoel, Ole J. (Carnegie Mellon University) | Metzler, Ted (Oklahoma City University) | Modayil, Joseph (University of Alberta) | Oard, Douglas W. (University of Maryland, College Park) | Onder, Nilufer (Michigan Technological University) | O' (University College Cork) | Sullivan, Barry (Cognitive Systems Research Insitute) | Pastra, Katerina (McGill University) | Precup, Doina (Stottler Henke Associates, Inc.) | Ramachandran, Sowmya (University of Dundee) | Reed, Chris (Istanbul Technical University) | Sariel-Talay, Sanem (Carnegie Mellon University) | Selker, Ted (Infosys Technologies Ltd.) | Shastri, Lokendra (Carnegie Mellon University) | Smith, Stephen F. (University of Michigan at Ann Arbor) | Singh, Satinder (University of Wisconsin, Madison) | Srivastava, Siddharth (University of Central Florida) | Sukthankar, Gita (Naval Research Laboratory) | Uthus, David C. (University of Technology, Sydney) | Williams, Mary-Anne
The AAAI-11 workshop program was held Sunday and Monday, August 7–18, 2011, at the Hyatt Regency San Francisco in San Francisco, California USA. The AAAI-11 workshop program included 15 workshops covering a wide range of topics in artificial intelligence. The titles of the workshops were Activity Context Representation: Techniques and Languages; Analyzing Microtext; Applied Adversarial Reasoning and Risk Modeling; Artificial Intelligence and Smarter Living: The Conquest of Complexity; AI for Data Center Management and Cloud Computing; Automated Action Planning for Autonomous Mobile Robots; Computational Models of Natural Argument; Generalized Planning; Human Computation; Human-Robot Interaction in Elder Care; Interactive Decision Theory and Game Theory; Language-Action Tools for Cognitive Artificial Agents: Integrating Vision, Action and Language; Lifelong Learning; Plan, Activity, and Intent Recognition; and Scalable Integration of Analytics and Visualization. This article presents short summaries of those events.