Reviews: Neural Taskonomy: Inferring the Similarity of Task-Derived Representations from Brain Activity

Having read the authors' response and the other reviews, I think I may have gotten a little overly excited about this paper, but I still think it is innovative and significant. In fact, I found the relationship between the two clusters in Figures 6a and 6b more convincing than I did originally. However, I am dropping my score a notch because, while I really like this paper, I believe it is in the top 50%, not the top 15% of NIPS papers. This is again, because the analysis is not as rigorous as one would like. Also, after having read the author's response and the other reviews, I have edited my review a bit below.