Reviews: GLoMo: Unsupervised Learning of Transferable Relational Graphs

This paper presents a method to transfer graph structures learned on unlabeled data to downstream tasks, which is a conceptual shift from existing research that aims to transfer features (e.g., embeddings). The method consists of jointly training a feature and graph predictor using an unsupervised objective (which are decoupled) and then extracting only the output of the graph predictor for downstream tasks, where it is multiplicatively applied to arbitrary features. The method yields small improvements on a variety of NLP and vision tasks, and the qualitative analysis of the learned graphs does not convince me that it learns "meaningful" substructures. Overall, however, the paper has a compelling and promising idea (graph transfer), and it seems like there is room to improve on its results, so I'm a weak accept. Detailed comments: - Is "unsupervisedly" a word? It sounds weird... - The objective function in eq 3 is interesting and could have potential uses outside of just graph induction, as it seems especially powerful from the ablations in table 2...