c45147dee729311ef5b5c3003946c48f-Reviews.html

UPDATED AFTER AUTHOR FEEDBACK AND OTHER REVIEWS: Based on the author rebuttal and the comments of the other reviewers, I still believe the paper is worthy of acceptance. However, I agree with the other reviewers that the paper merits a 1'' (incremental) rather than a 2'' (major novelty) in the impact score. ORIGINAL REVIEW: Summary: This paper proposes an image-based model for visual clutter perception ( a crowded, disorderly state''). For a given image, the model begins by applying an existing superpixel clustering then computing the intensity, colour and orientation histograms of pixels within each superpixel. Boundaries between adjacent superpixels are then retained or merged to create proto-objects''.