impressively engineered combination of multiple different techniques with associated hyperparameters: a warm-up

We are grateful to the reviewers for their time and their thoughtful comments, which we believe will improve the paper. We first clarify the comparison with DivideMix and then address all individual comments below. Following the same approach as DivideMix, the accuracy for ELR+ is the same or even higher (e.g. We will explain all of this in our revision, including possible limitations as suggested by Reviewer 3. The memorization effect is not new to the community. We believe that it may be due to a reduction in confirmation bias.