Review for NeurIPS paper: Early-Learning Regularization Prevents Memorization of Noisy Labels

Weaknesses: I have many reservation against the claims of the paper. I would appreciate it if the authors can clarify some of these issues during their rebuttal. First, the proof of their main theorem about logistic regression has many issues. One key issue is that the authors make assumptions within the proof that are not clearly stated or justified upfront. For example, in Line 440 in the supplementary materials, the proof assumes that theta Tv .1.