The Leaderboard Illusion

Measuring progress is fundamental to the advancement of any scientific field. As benchmarks play an increasingly central role, they also become more susceptible to distortion. Chatbot Arena has emerged as the go-to leaderboard for ranking the most capable AI systems. Yet, in this work we identify systematic issues that have skewed the competitive landscape. Specifically, undisclosed private testing practices benefit a handful of providers who are able to test multiple variants before public release and selectively retract scores.