Technology
Model Checking Command Dialogues
Medellin, Angel Rolando (University of Liverpool) | Atkinson, Katie (University of Liverpool) | McBurney, Peter (University of Liverpool)
Verification that agent communication protocols have desirable properties or do not have undesirable properties is an important issue in agent systems where agents intend to communicate using such protocols. In this paper we explore the use of model checkers to verify properties of agent communication protocols, with these properties expressed as formulae in temporal logic. We illustrate our approach using a recently-proposed protocol for agent dialogues over commands, a protocol that permits the agents to present questions, challenges and arguments for or against compliance with a command.
Formal Argumentation and Human Reasoning: The Case of Reinstatement
Madakkatel, Mohammed Iqbal (British University in Dubai) | Rahwan, Iyad (British University in Dubai &) | Bonnefon, Jean-Francois (University of Edinburgh) | Awan, Ruqiyabi Naz (CNRS and Universite de Toulouse) | Abdallah, Sherief (British University in Dubai)
Argumentation is now a very fertile area of research in Artificial Intelligence. Yet, most approaches to reasoning with arguments in AI are based on a normative perspective, relying on intuition as to what constitutes correct reasoning, sometimes aided by purpose-built hypothetical examples. For these models to be useful in agent-human argumentation, they can benefit from an alternative, positivist perspective that takes into account the empirical reality of human reasoning. To give a flavour of the kinds of lessons that this methodology can provide, we report on a psychological study exploring simple reinstatement in argumentation semantics. Empirical results show that while reinstatement is cognitively plausible in principle, it does not yield full recovery of the argument status, a notion not captured in Dung's classical model. This result suggests some possible avenues for research relevant to making formal models of argument more useful.
Action-State Semantics for Practical Reasoning
Bench-Capon, Trevor (University of Liverpool) | Atkinson, Katie (University of Liverpool)
There are two aspects of practical reasoning which present particular difficulties for current approaches to modelling practical reasoning through argumentation: temporal aspects, and the intrinsic worth of actions. Time is important because actions change the state of the world, we need to consider future states as well as past and present ones. Equally, it is often not what we do but the way that we do it that matters: the same future state may be reachable either through desirable or undesirable actions, and often also actions are done for their own sake rather than for the sake of their consequences. In this paper we will present a semantics for practical reasoning, based on a formalisation developed originally for reasoning about commands, in which actions and states are treated as of equal status. We will show how using these semantics facilitates the handling of the temporal aspects of practical reasoning, and enables, where appropriate, justification of actions without reference to their consequences.
Scenario Generation Using Double Scope Blending
Tan, Kian-Moh Terence (National University of Singapore) | Kwok, Kenneth (National University of Singapore)
Conceptual Blending through the process of Double Scope Blending provides an account for human creativity. We show how computational creativity can be modeled after Double Scope Blending for machine generation of scenarios, stories, hypotheses, etc. This paper describes an application of this process to the generation of novel and creative scenarios in the maritime security domain.
Transfer as a Benchmark for Multi-Representational Architectures
Klenk, Matthew Evans (Naval Research Laboratory)
We argue that transfer of spatial and conceptual knowledge between tasks and domains is an essential benchmark for multi-representational architectures aimed at human-level intelligence. The underlying hypothesis is that spatial relationships provide a natural level of abstraction, highlighting the similarities and differences between situations and domains. Therefore, not only will spatial representations improve domain reasoning and learning, they will also facilitate the transfer of knowledge across domains. The simulated environments of real-time strategy (RTS) games provide an excellent test-bed for exploring this hypothesis for two reasons: many different RTS domains have been constructed and RTS requires a wide range of reasoning tasks.
Integrating a Portfolio of Representations to Solve Hard Problems
Epstein, Susan (Hunter College and The Graduate Center of The City University of New York)
This paper advocates the use of a portfolio of representations for problem solving in complex domains. It describes an approach that decouples efficient storage mechanisms called descriptives from the decision-making procedures that employ them. An architecture that takes this approach can learn which representations are appropriate for a given problem class. Examples of search with a portfolio of representations are drawn from a broad set of domains.
Learning Topology of Curves with Application to Clustering
Mobahi, Hossein (University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign) | Rao, Shankar (University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign) | Ma, Yi (University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign)
We propose a method for learning the intrinsic topology of a point set sampled from a curve embedded in a high-dimensional ambient space. Our approach does not rely on distances in the ambient space, and thus can recover the topology of sparsely sampled curves, a situation where extant manifold learning methods are expected to fail. We formulate a loss function based on the smoothness of a curve, and derive a greedy procedure for minimizing this loss function. We compare the efficacy of our approach with representative manifold learning and hierarchical clustering methods on both real and synthetic data.
Robust Laplacian Eigenmaps Using Global Information
Roychowdhury, Shounak (University of Texas at Austin)
The Laplacian Eigenmap is a popular method for non-linear dimension reduction and data representation. This graph based method uses a Graph Laplacian matrix that closely approximates the Laplace-Beltrami operator which has properties that help to learn the structure of data lying on Riemaniann manifolds. However, the Graph Laplacian used in this method is derived from an intermediate graph that is built using local neighborhood information. In this paper we show that it possible to encapsulate global information represented by a Minimum Spanning Tree on the data set and use it for effective dimension reduction when local information is limited. The ability of MSTs to capture intrinsic dimension and intrinsic entropy of manifolds has been shown in a recent study. Based on that result we show that the use of local neighborhood and global graph can preserve the locality of the manifold. The experimental results validate the simultaneous use of local and global information for non-linear dimension reduction.
Thresholds of Behavioral Flexibility and Environmental Turbulence for Group Success
Jones-Rooy, Andrea (University of Michigan)
Agent adaptability — the ability of agents to change behavioral strategies when it is beneficial to do so — is presumed to be an important part of the robustness of complex adaptive systems (CAS). But, determining when changing behaviors is advantageous for agents has proven quite challenging in CAS research, as sometimes behavioral change is necessary, but other times it can impose costs that exceed benefits. I present the results from experiments using an agent-based model (ABM) designed to discover thresholds after which behavioral flexibility leads to improved societal-level outcomes in groups of agents in dynamic environments. The first major result is that there are thresholds in both levels of flexibility in agent behavior and in levels of turbulence in the environment below and above which there are marked differences in utility gains for agents. In particular, relatively high flexibility leads to lower overall utility scores, as well as, surprisingly, decreased diversity and increased inequality between agents. The second result is that at very high levels of environmental turbulence, the effects of the environment alone on agent utility overshadow any benefits to agents from flexible behavior strategies. This suggests, counter-intuitively, that the best strategy for agents in very dynamic environments is simply to keep behavior constant. The third major result is that there is an interaction between agent behavior and the environment: high flexibility of other agents can effectively make an environment more "dynamic", which just fuels more flexibility, and leads to a scramble between different strategies with no utility gain. A final theoretical contribution of the paper is that the model is able to show drawbacks to flexibility without relying on costs to changing behavior, as is done in much of the literature on strategy change.
Dynamics of Price Sensitivity and Market Structure in an Evolutionary Matching Model
Drutchas, Griffin Vernor (Kalamazoo College) | Érdi, Péter (Kalamazoo College)
The relationship between equilibrium convergence to a uniform quality distribution and price is investigated in the Q-model, a self-organizing, evolutionary computational matching model of a fixed-price post-secondary higher education created by Ortmann and Slobodyan (2006). The Q-model is replicated with price equaling 100% its Ortmann and Slobodyan (2006) value, Varying the fixed price between 0% and 200% reveals thresholds at which the Q-model reaches different market clustering configurations. Results indicate structural market robustness to prices less than 100% and high sensitivity to prices greater than 100%.