Uncertainty
Selecting Weighting Factors in Logarithmic Opinion Pools
A simple linear averaging of the outputs of several networks as e.g. in bagging [3], seems to follow naturally from a bias/variance decomposition of the sum-squared error. The sum-squared error of the average model is a quadratic function of the weighting factors assigned to the networks in the ensemble [7], suggesting a quadratic programming algorithm for finding the "optimal" weighting factors. If we interpret the output of a network as a probability statement, the sum-squared error corresponds to minus the loglikelihood or the Kullback-Leibler divergence, and linear averaging of the outputs tologarithmic averaging of the probability statements: the logarithmic opinion pool. The crux of this paper is that this whole story about model averaging, bias/variancedecompositions, and quadratic programming to find the optimal weighting factors, is not specific for the sumsquared error,but applies to the combination of probability statements of any kind in a logarithmic opinion pool, as long as the Kullback-Leibler divergence plays the role of the error measure. As examples we treat model averaging for classification models under a cross-entropy error measure and models for estimating variances.
Intelligent Data Analysis: Reasoning About Data
Berthold, Michael, Cohen, Paul R., Liu, Xiaohui
The Second International Symposium on Intelligent Data Analysis (IDA97) was held at Birkbeck College, University of London, on 4 to 6 August 1997. The main theme of IDA97 was to reason about how to analyze data,perhaps as human analysts do, by exploiting many methods from diverse disciplines. This article outlines several key issues and challenges, discusses how they were addressed at the conference, and presents opportunities for further work in the field.
Probabilistic Inference from Arbitrary Uncertainty using Mixtures of Factorized Generalized Gaussians
Ruiz, A., Lopez-de-Teruel, P. E., Garrido, M. C.
This paper presents a general and efficient framework for probabilistic inference and learning from arbitrary uncertain information. It exploits the calculation properties of finite mixture models, conjugate families and factorization. Both the joint probability density of the variables and the likelihood function of the (objective or subjective) observation are approximated by a special mixture model, in such a way that any desired conditional distribution can be directly obtained without numerical integration. We have developed an extended version of the expectation maximization (EM) algorithm to estimate the parameters of mixture models from uncertain training examples (indirect observations). As a consequence, any piece of exact or uncertain information about both input and output values is consistently handled in the inference and learning stages. This ability, extremely useful in certain situations, is not found in most alternative methods. The proposed framework is formally justified from standard probabilistic principles and illustrative examples are provided in the fields of nonparametric pattern classification, nonlinear regression and pattern completion. Finally, experiments on a real application and comparative results over standard databases provide empirical evidence of the utility of the method in a wide range of applications.
Ordered Classes and Incomplete Examples in Classification
The classes in classification tasks often have a natural ordering, and the training and testing examples are often incomplete. We propose a nonlinear ordinal model for classification into ordered classes. Predictive, simulation-based approaches are used to learn from past and classify future incomplete examples. These techniques are illustrated by making prognoses for patients who have suffered severe head injuries.
Analysis of Temporal-Diffference Learning with Function Approximation
Tsitsiklis, John N., Roy, Benjamin Van
We present new results about the temporal-difference learning algorithm, as applied to approximating the cost-to-go function of a Markov chain using linear function approximators. The algorithm we analyze performs online updating of a parameter vector during a single endless trajectory of an aperiodic irreducible finite state Markov chain. Results include convergence (with probability 1), a characterization of the limit of convergence, and a bound on the resulting approximation error. In addition to establishing new and stronger results than those previously available, our analysis is based on a new line of reasoning that provides new intuition about the dynamics of temporal-difference learning. Furthermore, we discuss the implications of two counterexamples with regards to the Significance of online updating and linearly parameterized function approximators. 1 INTRODUCTION The problem of predicting the expected long-term future cost (or reward) of a stochastic dynamic system manifests itself in both time-series prediction and control.
Local Bandit Approximation for Optimal Learning Problems
Duff, Michael O., Barto, Andrew G.
A Bayesian formulation of the problem leads to a clear concept of a solution whose computation, however, appears to entail an examination of an intractably-large number of hyperstates. This paper has suggested extending the Gittins index approach (which applies with great power and elegance to the special class of multi-armed bandit processes) to general adaptive MDP's. The hope has been that if certain salient features of the value of information could be captured, even approximately, then one could be led to a reasonable method for avoiding certain defects of certainty-equivalence approaches (problems with identifiability, "metastability"). Obviously, positive evidence, in the form of empirical results from simulation experiments, would lend support to these ideas-work along these lines is underway. Local bandit approximation is but one approximate computational approach for problems of optimal learning and dual control. Most prominent in the literature of control theory is the "wide-sense" approach of [Bar-Shalom & Tse, 1976], which utilizes local quadratic approximations about nominal state/control trajectories. For certain problems, this method has demonstrated superior performance compared to a certainty-equivalence approach, but it is computationally very intensive and unwieldy, particularly for problems with controller dimension greater than one. One could revert to the view of the bandit problem, or general adaptive MDP, as simply a very large MDP defined over hyperstates, and then consider a some- Local Bandit Approximationfor Optimal Learning Problems 1025 what direct approach in which one performs approximate dynamic programming with function approximation over this domain-details of function-approximation, feature-selection, and "training" all become important design issues.
Contour Organisation with the EM Algorithm
Leite, José A. F., Hancock, Edwin R.
This paper describes how the early visual process of contour organisation can be realised using the EM algorithm. The underlying computational representation is based on fine spline coverings. According to our EM approach the adjustment of spline parameters draws on an iterative weighted least-squares fitting process. The expectation step of our EM procedure computes the likelihood of the data using a mixture model defined over the set of spline coverings. These splines are limited in their spatial extent using Gaussian windowing functions.
Compositionality, MDL Priors, and Object Recognition
Bienenstock, Elie, Geman, Stuart, Potter, Daniel
Images are ambiguous at each of many levels of a contextual hierarchy. Nevertheless, the high-level interpretation of most scenes is unambiguous, as evidenced by the superior performance of humans. This observation argues for global vision models, such as deformable templates. Unfortunately, such models are computationally intractable for unconstrained problems. We propose a compositional model in which primitives are recursively composed, subject to syntactic restrictions, to form tree-structured objects and object groupings. Ambiguity is propagated up the hierarchy in the form of multiple interpretations, which are later resolved by a Bayesian, equivalently minimum-description-Iength, cost functional.
Maximum Likelihood Blind Source Separation: A Context-Sensitive Generalization of ICA
Pearlmutter, Barak A., Parra, Lucas C.
We cast the problem as one of maximum likelihood density estimation, and in that framework introduce an algorithm that searches for independent components using both temporal and spatial cues. We call the resulting algorithm "Contextual ICA," after the (Bell and Sejnowski 1995) Infomax algorithm, which we show to be a special case of cICA. Because cICA can make use of the temporal structure of its input, it is able separate in a number of situations where standard methods cannot, including sources with low kurtosis, colored Gaussian sources, and sources which have Gaussian histograms. 1 The Blind Source Separation Problem Consider a set of n indepent sources