Uncertainty
Viterbi training in PRISM
Sato, Taisuke, Kubota, Keiichi
VT (Viterbi training), or hard EM, is an efficient way of parameter learning for probabilistic models with hidden variables. Given an observation $y$, it searches for a state of hidden variables $x$ that maximizes $p(x,y \mid \theta)$ by coordinate ascent on parameters $\theta$ and $x$. In this paper we introduce VT to PRISM, a logic-based probabilistic modeling system for generative models. VT improves PRISM in three ways. First VT in PRISM converges faster than EM in PRISM due to the VT's termination condition. Second, parameters learned by VT often show good prediction performance compared to those learned by EM. We conducted two parsing experiments with probabilistic grammars while learning parameters by a variety of inference methods, i.e.\ VT, EM, MAP and VB. The result is that VT achieved the best parsing accuracy among them in both experiments. Also we conducted a similar experiment for classification tasks where a hidden variable is not a prediction target unlike probabilistic grammars. We found that in such a case VT does not necessarily yield superior performance. Third since VT always deals with a single probability of a single explanation, Viterbi explanation, the exclusiveness condition that is imposed on PRISM programs is no more required if we learn parameters by VT. Last but not least we can say that as VT in PRISM is general and applicable to any PRISM program, it largely reduces the need for the user to develop a specific VT algorithm for a specific model. Furthermore since VT in PRISM can be used just by setting a PRISM flag appropriately, it makes VT easily accessible to (probabilistic) logic programmers. To appear in Theory and Practice of Logic Programming (TPLP).
Gaussian Probabilities and Expectation Propagation
Cunningham, John P., Hennig, Philipp, Lacoste-Julien, Simon
While Gaussian probability densities are omnipresent in applied mathematics, Gaussian cumulative probabilities are hard to calculate in any but the univariate case. We study the utility of Expectation Propagation (EP) as an approximate integration method for this problem. For rectangular integration regions, the approximation is highly accurate. We also extend the derivations to the more general case of polyhedral integration regions. However, we find that in this polyhedral case, EP's answer, though often accurate, can be almost arbitrarily wrong. We consider these unexpected results empirically and theoretically, both for the problem of Gaussian probabilities and for EP more generally. These results elucidate an interesting and non-obvious feature of EP not yet studied in detail.
On Approximate Inference for Generalized Gaussian Process Models
Shang, Lifeng, Chan, Antoni B.
A generalized Gaussian process model (GGPM) is a unifying framework that encompasses many existing Gaussian process (GP) models, such as GP regression, classification, and counting. In the GGPM framework, the observation likelihood of the GP model is itself parameterized using the exponential family distribution (EFD). In this paper, we consider efficient algorithms for approximate inference on GGPMs using the general form of the EFD. A particular GP model and its associated inference algorithms can then be formed by changing the parameters of the EFD, thus greatly simplifying its creation for task-specific output domains. We demonstrate the efficacy of this framework by creating several new GP models for regressing to non-negative reals and to real intervals. We also consider a closed-form Taylor approximation for efficient inference on GGPMs, and elaborate on its connections with other model-specific heuristic closed-form approximations. Finally, we present a comprehensive set of experiments to compare approximate inference algorithms on a wide variety of GGPMs.
Summary Statistics for Partitionings and Feature Allocations
Fidaner, Işık Barış, Cemgil, Ali Taylan
Infinite mixture models are commonly used for clustering. One can sample from the posterior of mixture assignments by Monte Carlo methods or find its maximum a posteriori solution by optimization. However, in some problems the posterior is diffuse and it is hard to interpret the sampled partitionings. In this paper, we introduce novel statistics based on block sizes for representing sample sets of partitionings and feature allocations. We develop an element-based definition of entropy to quantify segmentation among their elements. Then we propose a simple algorithm called entropy agglomeration (EA) to summarize and visualize this information. Experiments on various infinite mixture posteriors as well as a feature allocation dataset demonstrate that the proposed statistics are useful in practice.
Unsupervised Sub-tree Alignment for Tree-to-Tree Translation
This article presents a probabilistic sub-tree alignment model and its application to tree-to-tree machine translation. Unlike previous work, we do not resort to surface heuristics or expensive annotated data, but instead derive an unsupervised model to infer the syntactic correspondence between two languages. More importantly, the developed model is syntactically-motivated and does not rely on word alignments. As a by-product, our model outputs a sub-tree alignment matrix encoding a large number of diverse alignments between syntactic structures, from which machine translation systems can efficiently extract translation rules that are often filtered out due to the errors in 1-best alignment. Experimental results show that the proposed approach outperforms three state-of-the-art baseline approaches in both alignment accuracy and grammar quality. When applied to machine translation, our approach yields a +1.0 BLEU improvement and a -0.9 TER reduction on the NIST machine translation evaluation corpora. With tree binarization and fuzzy decoding, it even outperforms a state-of-the-art hierarchical phrase-based system.
Learning Pairwise Graphical Models with Nonlinear Sufficient Statistics
Yuan, Xiao-Tong, Li, Ping, Zhang, Tong
We investigate a generic problem of learning pairwise exponential family graphical models with pairwise sufficient statistics defined by a global mapping function, e.g., Mercer kernels. This subclass of pairwise graphical models allow us to flexibly capture complex interactions among variables beyond pairwise product. We propose two $\ell_1$-norm penalized maximum likelihood estimators to learn the model parameters from i.i.d. samples. The first one is a joint estimator which estimates all the parameters simultaneously. The second one is a node-wise conditional estimator which estimates the parameters individually for each node. For both estimators, we show that under proper conditions the extra flexibility gained in our model comes at almost no cost of statistical and computational efficiency. We demonstrate the advantages of our model over state-of-the-art methods on synthetic and real datasets.
Nonparametric Bayesian models of hierarchical structure in complex networks
Schmidt, Mikkel N., Herlau, Tue, Mørup, Morten
Analyzing and understanding the structure of complex relational data is important in many applications including analysis of the connectivity in the human brain. Such networks can have prominent patterns on different scales, calling for a hierarchically structured model. We propose two non-parametric Bayesian hierarchical network models based on Gibbs fragmentation tree priors, and demonstrate their ability to capture nested patterns in simulated networks. On real networks we demonstrate detection of hierarchical structure and show predictive performance on par with the state of the art. We envision that our methods can be employed in exploratory analysis of large scale complex networks for example to model human brain connectivity.
Dealing with the Fuzziness of Human Reasoning
Voskoglou, Michael Gr., Subbotin, Igor Ya.
Reasoning, the most important human brain operation, is characterized by a degree of fuzziness. In the present paper we construct a fuzzy model for the reasoning process giving through the calculation of probabilities and possibilities of all possible individuals' profiles a quantitative/qualitative view of their behaviour during the above process. In this model the main stages of human reasoning (imagination, visualisation and generation of ideas) are represented as fuzzy subsets of a set of linguistic labels characterizing a person's performance in each stage. Further, using the coordinates of the centre of gravity of the graph of the corresponding membership function we develop a method of measuring the reasoning skills of a group of individuals. We also present a number of classroom experiments with student groups' of T. E. I. of Patras, Greece, illustrating our results in practice.
Streaming Variational Bayes
Broderick, Tamara, Boyd, Nicholas, Wibisono, Andre, Wilson, Ashia C., Jordan, Michael I.
We present SDA-Bayes, a framework for (S)treaming, (D)istributed, (A)synchronous computation of a Bayesian posterior. The framework makes streaming updates to the estimated posterior according to a user-specified approximation batch primitive. We demonstrate the usefulness of our framework, with variational Bayes (VB) as the primitive, by fitting the latent Dirichlet allocation model to two large-scale document collections. We demonstrate the advantages of our algorithm over stochastic variational inference (SVI) by comparing the two after a single pass through a known amount of data---a case where SVI may be applied---and in the streaming setting, where SVI does not apply.
A survey on independence-based Markov networks learning
Name Reference Comments KS Koller and Sahami (1996) - Not Sound - The first one of this type - Requires specifying MB size in advance GS Margaritis and Thrun (2000) - Sound in theory - Proposed to learn Bayesian network via the induction of neighbors of each variable - First proved such kind of algorithm - Works in two phases: grow and shrink IAMB and its variants Tsamardinos et al (2003) - Sound in theory - Actually variant of GS - Simple to implement - Time efficient - Very poor on data efficiency - IAMB's variants achieve better performance on data efficiency than IAMB HITON-PC/MB Aliferis et al (2003) - Not sound - Another trial to make use of the topology information to enhance data efficiency - Data efficiency comparable to IAMB - Much slower compared to IAMB Fast-IAMB Yaramakala and Margaritis (2005) - Sound in theory - No fundamental difference as compared to IAMB - Adds candidates more greedily to speed up the learning - Still poor on data efficiency performance MMPC/MB Tsamardinos et al (2006) - Not sound - The first to make use of the underling topology information - Much more data efficient compared to IAMB - Much slower compared to IAMB PCMB Peña et al (2007) - Sound in theory - Data efficient by making use of topology information - Poor on time efficiency - Distinguish spouses from parents/children - Distinguish some children from parents/children IPC-MB Fu and Desmarais (2008) - Sound in theory - Most data efficient compared with previous algorithms - Much faster than PCMB on computing - Distinguish spouses from parents/children - Distinguish some children from parents/children - Best tradeoff among this family of algorithms