Uncertainty
On the Efficiency of the Neuro-Fuzzy Classifier for User Knowledge Modeling Systems
Jeihaninejad, Ehsan, Rabiee, Azam
User knowledge modeling systems are used as the most effective technology for grabbing new user's attention. Moreover, the quality of service (QOS) is increased by these intelligent services. This paper proposes two user knowledge classifiers based on artificial neural networks used as one of the influential parts of knowledge modeling systems. We employed multi-layer perceptron (MLP) and adaptive neural fuzzy inference system (ANFIS) as the classifiers. Moreover, we used real data contains the user's degree of study time, repetition number, their performance in exam, as well as the learning percentage, as our classifier's inputs. Compared with well-known methods like KNN and Bayesian classifiers used in other research with the same data sets, our experiments present better performance. Although, the number of samples in the train set is not large enough, the performance of the neuro-fuzzy classifier in the test set is 98.6% which is the best result in comparison with others. However, the comparison of MLP toward the ANFIS results presents performance reduction, although the MLP performance is more efficient than other methods like Bayesian and KNN. As our goal is evaluating and reporting the efficiency of a neuro-fuzzy classifier for user knowledge modeling systems, we utilized many different evaluation metrics such as Receiver Operating Characteristic and the Area Under its Curve, Total Accuracy, and Kappa statistics.
11 Alternatives To Keras For Deep Learning Enthusiasts
Infer.NET is a machine learning framework for running Bayesian inference in graphical models. It provides state-of-the-art message-passing algorithms and statistical routines needed to perform inference for a wide variety of applications. There are various intuitive features in this framework such as rich modelling language, multiple inference algorithms, designed for large scale inference as well as user-extendable. With the help of this framework, various Bayesian models such as Bayes Point Machine classifiers, TrueSkill matchmaking, hidden Markov models, and Bayesian networks can be implemented with ease.
Attention for Inference Compilation
Harvey, William, Munk, Andreas, Baydin, Atılım Güneş, Bergholm, Alexander, Wood, Frank
Work in progress generative models written as programs. Conditions on these random variables are imposed through observe statements, while the sample statements define latent variables we seek to draw inference about. Common to the different languages is the existence of an inference backend, which contains one or more general inference methods. Recent research has addressed the task of making repeated inference less computationally expensive, by using upfront computation to reduce the cost of later executions, an approach known as amortized inference (Gershman and Goodman, 2014). One new method called inference compilation (IC) (Le et al., 2017) enables fast inference on arbitrarily complex and non-differentiable generative models. The approximate posterior distribution it learns can be combined with importance sampling at inference time, so that inference is asymptotically correct.
Deep Probabilistic Surrogate Networks for Universal Simulator Approximation
Munk, Andreas, Ścibior, Adam, Baydin, Atılım Güneş, Stewart, Andrew, Fernlund, Goran, Poursartip, Anoush, Wood, Frank
We present a framework for automatically structuring and training fast, approximate, deep neural surrogates of existing stochastic simulators. Unlike traditional approaches to surrogate modeling, our surrogates retain the interpretable structure of the reference simulators. The particular way we achieve this allows us to replace the reference simulator with the surrogate when undertaking amortized inference in the probabilistic programming sense. The fidelity and speed of our surrogates allow for not only faster "forward" stochastic simulation but also for accurate and substantially faster inference. We support these claims via experiments that involve a commercial composite-materials curing simulator. Employing our surrogate modeling technique makes inference an order of magnitude faster, opening up the possibility of doing simulator-based, non-invasive, just-in-time parts quality testing; in this case inferring safety-critical latent internal temperature profiles of composite materials undergoing curing from surface temperature profile measurements.
Online Gaussian LDA for Unsupervised Pattern Mining from Utility Usage Data
Mohamad, Saad, Bouchachia, Abdelhamid
Non-intrusive load monitoring (NILM) aims at separating a whole-home energy signal into its appliance components. Such method can be harnessed to provide various services to better manage and control energy consumption (optimal planning and saving). NILM has been traditionally approached from signal processing and electrical engineering perspectives. Recently, machine learning has started to play an important role in NILM. While most work has focused on supervised algorithms, unsupervised approaches can be more interesting and of practical use in real case scenarios. Specifically, they do not require labelled training data to be acquired from individual appliances and the algorithm can be deployed to operate on the measured aggregate data directly. In this paper, we propose a fully unsupervised NILM framework based on Bayesian hierarchical mixture models. In particular, we develop a new method based on Gaussian Latent Dirichlet Allocation (GLDA) in order to extract global components that summarise the energy signal. These components provide a representation of the consumption patterns. Designed to cope with big data, our algorithm, unlike existing NILM ones, does not focus on appliance recognition. To handle this massive data, GLDA works online. Another novelty of this work compared to the existing NILM is that the data involves different utilities (e.g, electricity, water and gas) as well as some sensors measurements. Finally, we propose different evaluation methods to analyse the results which show that our algorithm finds useful patterns.
Descriptive Dimensionality and Its Characterization of MDL-based Learning and Change Detection
This paper introduces a new notion of dimensionality of probabilistic models from an information-theoretic view point. We call it the "descriptive dimension"(Ddim). We show that Ddim coincides with the number of independent parameters for the parametric class, and can further be extended to real-valued dimensionality when a number of models are mixed. The paper then derives the rate of convergence of the MDL (Minimum Description Length) learning algorithm which outputs a normalized maximum likelihood (NML) distribution with model of the shortest NML codelength. The paper proves that the rate is governed by Ddim. The paper also derives error probabilities of the MDL-based test for multiple model change detection. It proves that they are also governed by Ddim. Through the analysis, we demonstrate that Ddim is an intrinsic quantity which characterizes the performance of the MDL-based learning and change detection.
Accurate Layerwise Interpretable Competence Estimation
Rajendran, Vickram, LeVine, William
Estimating machine learning performance 'in the wild' is both an important and unsolved problem. In this paper, we seek to examine, understand, and predict the pointwise competence of classification models. Our contributions are twofold: First, we establish a statistically rigorous definition of competence that generalizes the common notion of classifier confidence; second, we present the ALICE (Accurate Layerwise Interpretable Competence Estimation) Score, a pointwise competence estimator for any classifier. By considering distributional, data, and model uncertainty, ALICE empirically shows accurate competence estimation in common failure situations such as class-imbalanced datasets, out-of-distribution datasets, and poorly trained models. Our contributions allow us to accurately predict the competence of any classification model given any input and error function. We compare our score with state-of-the-art confidence estimators such as model confidence and Trust Score, and show significant improvements in competence prediction over these methods on datasets such as DIGITS, CIFAR10, and CIFAR100.
Rationally Inattentive Inverse Reinforcement Learning Explains YouTube Commenting Behavior
Hoiles, William, Krishnamurthy, Vikram, Pattanayak, Kunal
We consider a novel application of inverse reinforcement learning which involves modeling, learning and predicting the commenting behavior of YouTube viewers. Each group of users is modeled as a rationally inattentive Bayesian agent. Our methodology integrates three key components. First, to identify distinct commenting patterns, we use deep embedded clustering to estimate framing information (essential extrinsic features) that clusters users into distinct groups. Second, we present an inverse reinforcement learning algorithm that uses Bayesian revealed preferences to test for rationality: does there exist a utility function that rationalizes the given data, and if yes, can it be used to predict future behavior? Finally, we impose behavioral economics constraints stemming from rational inattention to characterize the attention span of groups of users.The test imposes a R{\'e}nyi mutual information cost constraint which impacts how the agent can select attention strategies to maximize their expected utility. After a careful analysis of a massive YouTube dataset, our surprising result is that in most YouTube user groups, the commenting behavior is consistent with optimizing a Bayesian utility with rationally inattentive constraints. The paper also highlights how the rational inattention model can accurately predict future commenting behavior. The massive YouTube dataset and analysis used in this paper are available on GitHub and completely reproducible.
Calibration tests in multi-class classification: A unifying framework
Widmann, David, Lindsten, Fredrik, Zachariah, Dave
In safety-critical applications a probabilistic model is usually required to be calibrated, i.e., to capture the uncertainty of its predictions accurately. In multi-class classification, calibration of the most confident predictions only is often not sufficient. We propose and study calibration measures for multi-class classification that generalize existing measures such as the expected calibration error, the maximum calibration error, and the maximum mean calibration error. We propose and evaluate empirically different consistent and unbiased estimators for a specific class of measures based on matrix-valued kernels. Importantly, these estimators can be interpreted as test statistics associated with well-defined bounds and approximations of the p-value under the null hypothesis that the model is calibrated, significantly improving the interpretability of calibration measures, which otherwise lack any meaningful unit or scale.
Integrating overlapping datasets using bivariate causal discovery
Causal knowledge is vital for effective reasoning in science, as causal relations, unlike correlations, allow one to reason about the outcomes of interventions. Algorithms that can discover causal relations from observational data are based on the assumption that all variables have been jointly measured in a single dataset. In many cases this assumption fails. Previous approaches to overcoming this shortcoming devised algorithms that returned all joint causal structures consistent with the conditional independence information contained in each individual dataset. But, as conditional independence tests only determine causal structure up to Markov equivalence, the number of consistent joint structures returned by these approaches can be quite large. The last decade has seen the development of elegant algorithms for discovering causal relations beyond conditional independence, which can distinguish among Markov equivalent structures. In this work we adapt and extend these so-called bivariate causal discovery algorithms to the problem of learning consistent causal structures from multiple datasets with overlapping variables belonging to the same generating process, providing a sound and complete algorithm that outperforms previous approaches on synthetic and real data.