Uncertainty
A User-Guided Bayesian Framework for Ensemble Feature Selection in Life Science Applications (UBayFS)
Jenul, Anna, Schrunner, Stefan, Pilz, Jürgen, Tomic, Oliver
Feature selection pursues two major goals: to improve generalizability and performance of predictive algorithms like classification, regression, or clustering models and to improve data understanding and interpretability. Both aspects are of significant interest in fields like healthcare, where major decisions may be based on data analysis. Here, two sources of information are available: large-scale collections of data from multiple sources and profound knowledge from domain experts. Previous works tend to handle these sources as opposites, see [4], or neglect expert knowledge completely, see [30]. However, a combination of both can be valuable to compensate for underdetermined problem setups from high-dimensional datasets. Moreover, meta-information on the feature set may leverage interpretability. Works such as [21] consider constraints between samples but neglect constraints between features. The extension of L1 regularization to the so-called Group Lasso [43] and its variants [19] account for block structure but cannot handle more complex constraint types. There is a lack of sophisticated probabilistic frameworks that tackle this issue and deliver transparent results.
PACMAN: PAC-style bounds accounting for the Mismatch between Accuracy and Negative log-loss
Vera, Matias, Vega, Leonardo Rey, Piantanida, Pablo
The ultimate performance of machine learning algorithms for classification tasks is usually measured in terms of the empirical error probability (or accuracy) based on a testing dataset. Whereas, these algorithms are optimized through the minimization of a typically different--more convenient--loss function based on a training set. For classification tasks, this loss function is often the negative log-loss that leads to the well-known cross-entropy risk which is typically better behaved (from a numerical perspective) than the error probability. Conventional studies on the generalization error do not usually take into account the underlying mismatch between losses at training and testing phases. In this work, we introduce an analysis based on point-wise PAC approach over the generalization gap considering the mismatch of testing based on the accuracy metric and training on the negative log-loss. We label this analysis PACMAN. Building on the fact that the mentioned mismatch can be written as a likelihood ratio, concentration inequalities can be used to provide some insights for the generalization problem in terms of some point-wise PAC bounds depending on some meaningful information-theoretic quantities. An analysis of the obtained bounds and a comparison with available results in the literature are also provided.
A Novel Tropical Geometry-based Interpretable Machine Learning Method: Application in Prognosis of Advanced Heart Failure
Yao, Heming, Derksen, Harm, Golbus, Jessica R., Zhang, Justin, Aaronson, Keith D., Gryak, Jonathan, Najarian, Kayvan
A model's interpretability is essential to many practical applications such as clinical decision support systems. In this paper, a novel interpretable machine learning method is presented, which can model the relationship between input variables and responses in humanly understandable rules. The method is built by applying tropical geometry to fuzzy inference systems, wherein variable encoding functions and salient rules can be discovered by supervised learning. Experiments using synthetic datasets were conducted to investigate the performance and capacity of the proposed algorithm in classification and rule discovery. Furthermore, the proposed method was applied to a clinical application that identified heart failure patients that would benefit from advanced therapies such as heart transplant or durable mechanical circulatory support. Experimental results show that the proposed network achieved great performance on the classification tasks. In addition to learning humanly understandable rules from the dataset, existing fuzzy domain knowledge can be easily transferred into the network and used to facilitate model training. From our results, the proposed model and the ability of learning existing domain knowledge can significantly improve the model generalizability. The characteristics of the proposed network make it promising in applications requiring model reliability and justification.
The Peril of Popular Deep Learning Uncertainty Estimation Methods
Liu, Yehao, Pagliardini, Matteo, Chavdarova, Tatjana, Stich, Sebastian U.
Uncertainty estimation (UE) techniques -- such as the Gaussian process (GP), Bayesian neural networks (BNN), Monte Carlo dropout (MCDropout) -- aim to improve the interpretability of machine learning models by assigning an estimated uncertainty value to each of their prediction outputs. However, since too high uncertainty estimates can have fatal consequences in practice, this paper analyzes the above techniques. Firstly, we show that GP methods always yield high uncertainty estimates on out of distribution (OOD) data. Secondly, we show on a 2D toy example that both BNNs and MCDropout do not give high uncertainty estimates on OOD samples. Finally, we show empirically that this pitfall of BNNs and MCDropout holds on real world datasets as well. Our insights (i) raise awareness for the more cautious use of currently popular UE methods in Deep Learning, (ii) encourage the development of UE methods that approximate GP-based methods -- instead of BNNs and MCDropout, and (iii) our empirical setups can be used for verifying the OOD performances of any other UE method. The source code is available at https://github.com/epfml/uncertainity-estimation.
Learnable Faster Kernel-PCA for Nonlinear Fault Detection: Deep Autoencoder-Based Realization
Ren, Zelin, Yang, Xuebing, Jiang, Yuchen, Zhang, Wensheng
Kernel principal component analysis (KPCA) is a well-recognized nonlinear dimensionality reduction method that has been widely used in nonlinear fault detection tasks. As a kernel trick-based method, KPCA inherits two major problems. First, the form and the parameters of the kernel function are usually selected blindly, depending seriously on trial-and-error. As a result, there may be serious performance degradation in case of inappropriate selections. Second, at the online monitoring stage, KPCA has much computational burden and poor real-time performance, because the kernel method requires to leverage all the offline training data. In this work, to deal with the two drawbacks, a learnable faster realization of the conventional KPCA is proposed. The core idea is to parameterize all feasible kernel functions using the novel nonlinear DAE-FE (deep autoencoder based feature extraction) framework and propose DAE-PCA (deep autoencoder based principal component analysis) approach in detail. The proposed DAE-PCA method is proved to be equivalent to KPCA but has more advantage in terms of automatic searching of the most suitable nonlinear high-dimensional space according to the inputs. Furthermore, the online computational efficiency improves by approximately 100 times compared with the conventional KPCA. With the Tennessee Eastman (TE) process benchmark, the effectiveness and superiority of the proposed method is illustrated.
Aggregation of Pareto optimal models
Bajgiran, Hamed Hamze, Owhadi, Houman
In statistical decision theory, a model is said to be Pareto optimal (or admissible) if no other model carries less risk for at least one state of nature while presenting no more risk for others. How can you rationally aggregate/combine a finite set of Pareto optimal models while preserving Pareto efficiency? This question is nontrivial because weighted model averaging does not, in general, preserve Pareto efficiency. This paper presents an answer in four logical steps: (1) A rational aggregation rule should preserve Pareto efficiency (2) Due to the complete class theorem, Pareto optimal models must be Bayesian, i.e., they minimize a risk where the true state of nature is averaged with respect to some prior. Therefore each Pareto optimal model can be associated with a prior, and Pareto efficiency can be maintained by aggregating Pareto optimal models through their priors. (3) A prior can be interpreted as a preference ranking over models: prior $\pi$ prefers model A over model B if the average risk of A is lower than the average risk of B. (4) A rational/consistent aggregation rule should preserve this preference ranking: If both priors $\pi$ and $\pi'$ prefer model A over model B, then the prior obtained by aggregating $\pi$ and $\pi'$ must also prefer A over B. Under these four steps, we show that all rational/consistent aggregation rules are as follows: Give each individual Pareto optimal model a weight, introduce a weak order/ranking over the set of Pareto optimal models, aggregate a finite set of models S as the model associated with the prior obtained as the weighted average of the priors of the highest-ranked models in S. This result shows that all rational/consistent aggregation rules must follow a generalization of hierarchical Bayesian modeling. Following our main result, we present applications to Kernel smoothing, time-depreciating models, and voting mechanisms.
Model-Value Inconsistency as a Signal for Epistemic Uncertainty
Filos, Angelos, Vértes, Eszter, Marinho, Zita, Farquhar, Gregory, Borsa, Diana, Friesen, Abram, Behbahani, Feryal, Schaul, Tom, Barreto, André, Osindero, Simon
Using a model of the environment and a value function, an agent can construct many estimates of a state's value, by unrolling the model for different lengths and bootstrapping with its value function. Our key insight is that one can treat this set of value estimates as a type of ensemble, which we call an \emph{implicit value ensemble} (IVE). Consequently, the discrepancy between these estimates can be used as a proxy for the agent's epistemic uncertainty; we term this signal \emph{model-value inconsistency} or \emph{self-inconsistency} for short. Unlike prior work which estimates uncertainty by training an ensemble of many models and/or value functions, this approach requires only the single model and value function which are already being learned in most model-based reinforcement learning algorithms. We provide empirical evidence in both tabular and function approximation settings from pixels that self-inconsistency is useful (i) as a signal for exploration, (ii) for acting safely under distribution shifts, and (iii) for robustifying value-based planning with a model.
On the Effectiveness of Mode Exploration in Bayesian Model Averaging for Neural Networks
Holodnak, John T., Wollaber, Allan B.
Multiple techniques for producing calibrated predictive probabilities using deep neural networks in supervised learning settings have emerged that leverage approaches to ensemble diverse solutions discovered during cyclic training or training from multiple random starting points (deep ensembles). However, only a limited amount of work has investigated the utility of exploring the local region around each diverse solution (posterior mode). Using three well-known deep architectures on the CIFAR-10 dataset, we evaluate several simple methods for exploring local regions of the weight space with respect to Brier score, accuracy, and expected calibration error. We consider both Bayesian inference techniques (variational inference and Hamiltonian Monte Carlo applied to the softmax output layer) as well as utilizing the stochastic gradient descent trajectory near optima. While adding separate modes to the ensemble uniformly improves performance, we show that the simple mode exploration methods considered here produce little to no improvement over ensembles without mode exploration.
A Bayesian take on option pricing with Gaussian processes
Tegner, Martin, Roberts, Stephen
Local volatility is a versatile option pricing model due to its state dependent diffusion coefficient. Calibration is, however, non-trivial as it involves both proposing a hypothesis model of the latent function and a method for fitting it to data. In this paper we present novel Bayesian inference with Gaussian process priors. We obtain a rich representation of the local volatility function with a probabilistic notion of uncertainty attached to the calibrate. We propose an inference algorithm and apply our approach to S&P 500 market data.
Bayesian Learning via Neural Schr\"odinger-F\"ollmer Flows
Vargas, Francisco, Ovsianas, Andrius, Fernandes, David, Girolami, Mark, Lawrence, Neil D., Nüsken, Nikolas
In this work we explore a new framework for approximate Bayesian inference in large datasets based on stochastic control. We advocate stochastic control as a finite time and low variance alternative to popular steady-state methods such as stochastic gradient Langevin dynamics (SGLD). Furthermore, we discuss and adapt the existing theoretical guarantees of this framework and establish connections to already existing VI routines in SDE-based models.