Goto

Collaborating Authors

 Planning & Scheduling


Probabilistic Plan Recognition Using Off-the-Shelf Classical Planners

AAAI Conferences

Plan recognition is the problem of inferring the goals and plans of an agent after observing its behavior. Recently, it has been shown that this problem can be solved efficiently, without the need of a plan library, using slightly modified planning algorithms. In this work, we extend this approach to the more general problem of probabilistic plan recognition where a probability distribution over the set of goals is sought under the assumptions that actions have deterministic effects and both agent and observer have complete information about the initial state. We show that this problem can be solved efficiently using classical planners provided that the probability of a partially observed execution given a goal is defined in terms of the cost difference of achieving the goal under two conditions: complying with the observations, and not complying with them. This cost, and hence the posterior goal probabilities, are computed by means of two calls to a classical planner that no longer has to be modified in any way. A number of examples is considered to illustrate the quality, flexibility, and scalability of the approach.


Learning Methods to Generate Good Plans: Integrating HTN Learning and Reinforcement Learning

AAAI Conferences

We consider how to learn Hierarchical Task Networks (HTNs) for planning problems in which both the quality of solution plans generated by the HTNs and the speed at which those plans are found is important. We describe an integration of HTN Learning with Reinforcement Learning to both learn methods by analyzing semantic annotations on tasks and to produce estimates of the expected values of the learned methods by performing Monte Carlo updates. We performed an experiment in which plan quality was inversely related to plan length. In two planning domains, we evaluated the planning performance of the learned methods in comparison to two state-of-the-art satisficing classical planners, FastForward and SGPlan6, and one optimal planner, HSP*. The results demonstrate that a greedy HTN planner using the learned methods was able to generate higher quality solutions than SGPlan6 in both domains and FastForward in one. Our planner, FastForward, and SGPlan6 ran in similar time, while HSP* was exponentially slower.


Optimizing Limousine Service with AI

AAAI Conferences

A common problem faced by expanding companies is the lack of skilled and experienced domain experts, especially planners and controllers. This can seriously slow down or impede growth. This paper describes how we worked with one of the largest travel agencies in Hong Kong to alleviate this problem by using AI to support decision-making and problem-solving so that their planners/controllers can be more productive in sustaining business growth while providing quality service. This paper describes a Web-based mission critical Fleet Management System (FMS) that supports the scheduling and management of a fleet of luxury limousines. Clientele is mainly business travelers. The use of AI allowed our client to increase their business volume and expand fleet size with the same team of planners/controllers while maintaining service quality. This paper also describes our experience in building modern AI systems leveraging on Web 2.0 open-source tools and libraries. Although we used a proven AI model and search algorithm, we believe our innovation is in striking the right balance and combination of AI with modern Web 2.0 techniques to achieve low-risk implementation and deployment success as well as concrete and measurable business benefits.


SixthSense: Fast and Reliable Recognition of Dead Ends in MDPs

AAAI Conferences

The results of the latest International Probabilistic Planning Competition (IPPC-2008) indicate that the presence of dead ends, states with no trajectory to the goal, makes MDPs hard for modern probabilistic planners. Implicit dead ends, states with executable actions but no path to the goal, are particularly challenging; existing MDP solvers spend much time and memory identifying these states. As a first attempt to address this issue, we propose a machine learning algorithm called SIXTHSENSE. SIXTHSENSE helps existing MDP solvers by finding nogoods, conjunctions of literals whose truth in a state implies that the state is a dead end. Importantly, our learned nogoods are sound, and hence the states they identify are true dead ends. SIXTHSENSE is very fast, needs little training data, and takes only a small fraction of total planning time. While IPPC problems may have millions of dead ends, they may typically be represented with only a dozen or two no-goods. Thus, nogood learning efficiently produces a quick and reliable means for dead-end recognition. Our experiments show that the nogoods found by SIXTHSENSE routinely reduce planning space and time on IPPC domains, enabling some planners to solve problems they could not previously handle.


Search-Based Path Planning with Homotopy Class Constraints

AAAI Conferences

Goal-directed path planning is one of the basic and widely studied problems in the field of mobile robotics. Homotopy classes of trajectories, arising due to the presence of obstacles, are defined as sets of trajectories that can be transformed into each other by gradual bending and stretching without colliding with obstacles. The problem of finding least-cost paths restricted to a specific homotopy class or finding least-cost paths that do not belong to certain homotopy classes arises frequently in such applications as predicting paths for dynamic entities and computing heuristics for path planning with dynamic constraints. In the present work, we develop a compact way of representing homotopy classes and propose an efficient method of graph search-based optimal path planning with constraints on homotopy classes. The method is based on representing the environment of the robot as a complex plane and making use of the Cauchy Integral Theorem. We prove optimality of the method and show its efficiency experimentally.


Planning in Dynamic Environments: Extending HTNs with Nonlinear Continuous Effects

AAAI Conferences

Planning in dynamic continuous environments requires reasoning about nonlinear continuous effects, which previous Hierarchical Task Network (HTN) planners do not support. In this paper, we extend an existing HTN planner with a new state projection algorithm. To our knowledge, this is the first HTN planner that can reason about nonlinear continuous effects. We use a wait action to instruct this planner to consider continuous effects in a given state. We also introduce a new planning domain to demonstrate the benefits of planning with nonlinear continuous effects. We compare our approach with a linear continuous effects planner and a discrete effects HTN planner on a benchmark domain, which reveals that its additional costs are largely mitigated by domain knowledge. Finally, we present an initial application of this algorithm in a practical domain, a Navy training simulation, illustrating the utility of this approach for planning in dynamic continuous environments.


The Model-Based Approach to Autonomous Behavior: A Personal View

AAAI Conferences

The selection of the action to do next is one of the central problems faced by autonomous agents. In AI, three approaches have been used to address this problem: the programming-based approach, where the agent controller is given by the programmer, the learning-based approach, where the controller is induced from experience via a learning algorithm, and the model-based approach, where the controller is derived from a model of the problem. Planning in AI is best conceived as the model-based approach to action selection. The models represent the initial situation, actions, sensors, and goals. The main challenge in planning is computational, as all the models, whether accommodating feedback and uncertainty or not, are intractable in the worst case. In this article, I review some of the models considered in current planning research, the progress achieved in solving these models, and some of the open problems.


Multi-Agent Plan Recognition: Formalization and Algorithms

AAAI Conferences

Multi-Agent Plan Recognition (MAPR) seeks to identify the dynamic team structures and team behaviors from the observations of the activity-sequences of a set of intelligent agents, based on a library of known team-activities (plan library). It has important applications in analyzing data from automated monitoring, surveillance, and intelligence analysis in general. In this paper, we formalize MAPR using a basic model that explicates the cost of abduction in single agent plan recognition by "flattening" or decompressing the (usually compact, hierarchical) plan library. We show that single-agent plan recognition with a decompressed library can be solved in time polynomial in the input size, while it is known that with a compressed (by partial ordering constraints) library it is NP-complete. This leads to an important insight: that although the compactness of the plan library plays an important role in the hardness of single-agent plan recognition (as recognized in the existing literature), that is not the case with multiple agents. We show, for the first time, that MAPR is NP-complete even when the (multi-agent) plan library is fully decompressed. As with previous solution approaches, we break the problem into two stages: hypothesis generation and hypothesis search. We show that Knuth's ``Algorithm X'' (with the efficient ``dancing links'' representation) is particularly suited for our model, and can be adapted to perform a branch and bound search for the second stage, in this model. We show empirically that this new approach leads to significant pruning of the hypothesis space in MAPR.


Temporal Planning for Interacting Durative Actions with Continuous Effects

AAAI Conferences

We consider planning domains with both discrete and continuous changes. Continuous change occurs especially when agents share time-dependent critical resources. In these cases, besides discrete and continuous changes, their interactions should also be taken into consideration. However concurrency of durative actions with interacting continuous effects cannot be exploited by existing temporal planners. To overcome this problem, we propose an action lifting approach and we analyze path sharing problem to illustrate interaction of continuous linear effects in the planning domain.


Goal-Driven Autonomy in a Navy Strategy Simulation

AAAI Conferences

Modern complex games and simulations pose many challenges for an intelligent agent, including partial observability, continuous time and effects, hostile opponents, and exogenous events. We present ARTUE (Autonomous Response to Unexpected Events), a domain-independent autonomous agent that dynamically reasons about what goals to pursue in response to unexpected circumstances in these types of environments. ARTUE integrates AI research in planning, environment monitoring, explanation, goal generation, and goal management. To explain our conceptualization of the problem ARTUE addresses, we present a new conceptual framework, goal-driven autonomy, for agents that reason about their goals. We evaluate ARTUE on scenarios in the TAO Sandbox, a Navy training simulation, and demonstrate its novel architecture, which includes components for Hierarchical Task Network planning, explanation, and goal management. Our evaluation shows that ARTUE can perform well in a complex environment and that each component is necessary and contributes to the performance of the integrated system.