Statistical Learning
Spectral Methods meet EM: A Provably Optimal Algorithm for Crowdsourcing
Zhang, Yuchen, Chen, Xi, Zhou, Dengyong, Jordan, Michael I.
Crowdsourcing is a popular paradigm for effectively collecting labels at low cost. The Dawid-Skene estimator has been widely used for inferring the true labels from the noisy labels provided by non-expert crowdsourcing workers. However, since the estimator maximizes a non-convex log-likelihood function, it is hard to theoretically justify its performance. In this paper, we propose a two-stage efficient algorithm for multi-class crowd labeling problems. The first stage uses the spectral method to obtain an initial estimate of parameters. Then the second stage refines the estimation by optimizing the objective function of the Dawid-Skene estimator via the EM algorithm. We show that our algorithm achieves the optimal convergence rate up to a logarithmic factor. We conduct extensive experiments on synthetic and real datasets. Experimental results demonstrate that the proposed algorithm is comparable to the most accurate empirical approach, while outperforming several other recently proposed methods.
Entropy of Overcomplete Kernel Dictionaries
In signal analysis and synthesis, linear approximation theory considers a linear decomposition of any given signal in a set of atoms, collected into a so-called dictionary. Relevant sparse representations are obtained by relaxing the orthogonality condition of the atoms, yielding overcomplete dictionaries with an extended number of atoms. More generally than the linear decomposition, overcomplete kernel dictionaries provide an elegant nonlinear extension by defining the atoms through a mapping kernel function (e.g., the gaussian kernel). Models based on such kernel dictionaries are used in neural networks, gaussian processes and online learning with kernels. The quality of an overcomplete dictionary is evaluated with a diversity measure the distance, the approximation, the coherence and the Babel measures. In this paper, we develop a framework to examine overcomplete kernel dictionaries with the entropy from information theory. Indeed, a higher value of the entropy is associated to a further uniform spread of the atoms over the space. For each of the aforementioned diversity measures, we derive lower bounds on the entropy. Several definitions of the entropy are examined, with an extensive analysis in both the input space and the mapped feature space.
To Re(label), or Not To Re(label)
Lin, Christopher H. (University of Washington) | Mausam, . (Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi) | Weld, Daniel S (University of Washington)
One of the most popular uses of crowdsourcing is to provide training data for supervised machine learning algorithms. Since human annotators often make errors, requesters commonly ask multiple workers to label each example. ย But is this strategy always the most cost effective use of crowdsourced workers? We argue "No" --- often classifiers can achieve higher accuracies when trained with noisy "unilabeled" data. However, in some cases relabeling is extremely important. ย We discuss three factors that may make relabeling an effective strategy: classifier expressiveness, worker accuracy, and budget.
Predicting Next Label Quality: A Time-Series Model of Crowdwork
Jung, Hyun Joon (University of Texas at Austin) | Park, Yubin (University of Texas at Austin) | Lease, Matthew (University of Texas at Austin)
While temporal behavioral patterns can be discerned to underlie real crowd work, prior studies have typically modeled worker performance under a simplified i.i.d. assumption. To better model such temporal worker behavior, we propose a time-series label prediction model for crowd work. This latent variable model captures and summarizes past worker behavior, enabling us to better predict the quality of each worker's next label. Given inherent uncertainty in prediction, we also investigate a decision reject option to balance the tradeoff between prediction accuracy vs. coverage. Results show our model improves accuracy of both label prediction on real crowd worker data, as well as data quality overall.
Product Concept Evaluation System Applying Preference Market
Imai, Miku (Aoyama Gakuin University) | Mizuyama, Hajime (Aoyama Gakuin University)
A product concept evaluation system combining conjoint analysis with prediction markets is developed. It is also proposed how to determine the payoff for each prediction security corresponding to a product concept, so as to have participants to behave truthfully in the market. Further, how the proposed system works is investigated by evolutionary game simulation.
Quality Control for Crowdsourced Enumeration Tasks
Kajimura, Shunsuke (The University of Tokyo) | Baba, Yukino (National Institute of Informatics) | Kajino, Hiroshi (The University of Tokyo) | Kashima, Hisashi (Kyoto University)
Quality control is one of the central issues in crowdsourcing research. In this paper, we consider a quality control problem of crowdsourced enumeration tasks that request workers to enumerate possible answers as many as possible. Since workers neither necessarily provide correct answers nor provide exactly the same answers even if the answers indicate the same idea, we propose a two-stage quality control method consisting of the answer clustering stage and the reliability estimation stage.
Semi-Supervised Learning with Deep Generative Models
Kingma, Diederik P., Rezende, Danilo J., Mohamed, Shakir, Welling, Max
The ever-increasing size of modern data sets combined with the difficulty of obtaining label information has made semi-supervised learning one of the problems of significant practical importance in modern data analysis. We revisit the approach to semi-supervised learning with generative models and develop new models that allow for effective generalisation from small labelled data sets to large unlabelled ones. Generative approaches have thus far been either inflexible, inefficient or non-scalable. We show that deep generative models and approximate Bayesian inference exploiting recent advances in variational methods can be used to provide significant improvements, making generative approaches highly competitive for semi-supervised learning.
Partition-wise Linear Models
Oiwa, Hidekazu, Fujimaki, Ryohei
Region-specific linear models are widely used in practical applications because of their non-linear but highly interpretable model representations. One of the key challenges in their use is non-convexity in simultaneous optimization of regions and region-specific models. This paper proposes novel convex region-specific linear models, which we refer to as partition-wise linear models. Our key ideas are 1) assigning linear models not to regions but to partitions (region-specifiers) and representing region-specific linear models by linear combinations of partition-specific models, and 2) optimizing regions via partition selection from a large number of given partition candidates by means of convex structured regularizations. In addition to providing initialization-free globally-optimal solutions, our convex formulation makes it possible to derive a generalization bound and to use such advanced optimization techniques as proximal methods and decomposition of the proximal maps for sparsity-inducing regularizations. Experimental results demonstrate that our partition-wise linear models perform better than or are at least competitive with state-of-the-art region-specific or locally linear models.
Feedback Detection for Live Predictors
Wager, Stefan, Chamandy, Nick, Muralidharan, Omkar, Najmi, Amir
A predictor that is deployed in a live production system may perturb the features it uses to make predictions. Such a feedback loop can occur, for example, when a model that predicts a certain type of behavior ends up causing the behavior it predicts, thus creating a self-fulfilling prophecy. In this paper we analyze predictor feedback detection as a causal inference problem, and introduce a local randomization scheme that can be used to detect non-linear feedback in real-world problems. We conduct a pilot study for our proposed methodology using a predictive system currently deployed as a part of a search engine.
Sparse principal component regression with adaptive loading
Kawano, Shuichi, Fujisawa, Hironori, Takada, Toyoyuki, Shiroishi, Toshihiko
Principal component regression (PCR) is a two-stage procedure that selects some principal components and then constructs a regression model regarding them as new explanatory variables. Note that the principal components are obtained from only explanatory variables and not considered with the response variable. To address this problem, we propose the sparse principal component regression (SPCR) that is a one-stage procedure for PCR. SPCR enables us to adaptively obtain sparse principal component loadings that are related to the response variable and select the number of principal components simultaneously. SPCR can be obtained by the convex optimization problem for each of parameters with the coordinate descent algorithm. Monte Carlo simulations and real data analyses are performed to illustrate the effectiveness of SPCR.