Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) have become a very popular tool for implicitly learning high-dimensional probability distributions. Several improvements have been made to the original GAN formulation to address some of its shortcomings like mode collapse, convergence issues, entanglement, poor visual quality etc. While a significant effort has been directed towards improving the visual quality of images generated by GANs, it is rather surprising that objective image quality metrics have neither been employed as cost functions nor as regularizers in GAN objective functions. In this work, we show how a distance metric that is a variant of the Structural SIMilarity (SSIM) index (a popular full-reference image quality assessment algorithm), and a novel quality aware discriminator gradient penalty function that is inspired by the Natural Image Quality Evaluator (NIQE, a popular no-reference image quality assessment algorithm) can each be used as excellent regularizers for GAN objective functions. Specifically, we demonstrate state-of-the-art performance using the Wasserstein GAN gradient penalty (WGAN-GP) framework over CIFAR-10, STL10 and CelebA datasets.

I have read it carefully. The new experiments look good, but the authors do not seem to respond to my concern over SSIM metric between unpaired images. I keep my original review and rating. Given all the prior works that smooth GAN training, the idea that integrates image quality assessment metrics with GANs sounds interesting. From the experiment samples, it seems that the quality aware gan does improve the sample quality, the generated CelebA and STL images look sharp.

The paper proposes a novel way to regularize training of deep adversarial generative models for natural images. The proposal is based on using the image quality metrics. While many different ways of stabilizing and regularizing GAN training were proposed in prior work, most of which based on various gradient penalties related to the Lipschitzness, this submission proposes an idea which is significantly different and novel. The paper evaluates the new method on three reasonably challenging datasets (CIFAR-10, STL-10, CelebA) and quantitatively shows objective advantages to other methods (in terms of FID and IS). The field of GANs and in particular various ways to stabilize their training has been recently attracting perhaps excessive amount of attention with many papers proposing multiple methods very similar in nature.

Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) have become a very popular tool for im- plicitly learning high-dimensional probability distributions. Several improvements have been made to the original GAN formulation to address some of its shortcom- ings like mode collapse, convergence issues, entanglement, poor visual quality etc. While a significant effort has been directed towards improving the visual quality of images generated by GANs, it is rather surprising that objective image quality metrics have neither been employed as cost functions nor as regularizers in GAN objective functions. In this work, we show how a distance metric that is a variant of the Structural SIMilarity (SSIM) index (a popular full-reference image quality assessment algorithm), and a novel quality aware discriminator gradient penalty function that is inspired by the Natural Image Quality Evaluator (NIQE, a popular no-reference image quality assessment algorithm) can each be used as excellent regularizers for GAN objective functions. Specifically, we demonstrate state-of- the-art performance using the Wasserstein GAN gradient penalty (WGAN-GP) framework over CIFAR-10, STL10 and CelebA datasets.

Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) have become a very popular tool for im- plicitly learning high-dimensional probability distributions. Several improvements have been made to the original GAN formulation to address some of its shortcom- ings like mode collapse, convergence issues, entanglement, poor visual quality etc. While a significant effort has been directed towards improving the visual quality of images generated by GANs, it is rather surprising that objective image quality metrics have neither been employed as cost functions nor as regularizers in GAN objective functions. In this work, we show how a distance metric that is a variant of the Structural SIMilarity (SSIM) index (a popular full-reference image quality assessment algorithm), and a novel quality aware discriminator gradient penalty function that is inspired by the Natural Image Quality Evaluator (NIQE, a popular no-reference image quality assessment algorithm) can each be used as excellent regularizers for GAN objective functions. Specifically, we demonstrate state-of- the-art performance using the Wasserstein GAN gradient penalty (WGAN-GP) framework over CIFAR-10, STL10 and CelebA datasets.