Network representation learning has become an active research area in recent years with many new methods showcasing their performance on downstream prediction tasks such as Link Prediction. Despite the efforts of the community to ensure reproducibility of research by providing method implementations, important issues remain. The complexity of the evaluation pipelines and abundance of design choices have led to difficulties in quantifying the progress in the field and identifying the state-of-the-art. In this work, we analyse 17 network embedding methods on 7 real-world datasets and find, using a consistent evaluation pipeline, only thin progress over the recent years. Also, many embedding methods are outperformed by simple heuristics. Finally, we discuss how standardized evaluation tools can repair this situation and boost progress in this field.

With the widespread use of information technologies, information networks have increasingly become popular to capture complex relationships across various disciplines, such as social networks, citation networks, telecommunication networks, and biological networks. Analyzing these networks sheds light on different aspects of social life such as the structure of society, information diffusion, and different patterns of communication. However, the large scale of information networks often makes network analytic tasks computationally expensive and intractable. Recently, network representation learning has been proposed as a new learning paradigm that embeds network vertices into a low-dimensional vector space, by preserving network topology structure, vertex content, and other side information. This facilitates the original network to be easily handled in the new vector space for further analysis. In this survey, we perform a thorough review of the current literature on network representation learning in the field of data mining and machine learning. We propose a new categorization to analyze and summarize state-of-the-art network representation learning techniques according to the methodology they employ and the network information they preserve. Finally, to facilitate research on this topic, we summarize benchmark datasets and evaluation methodologies, and discuss open issues and future research directions in this field.