contingent plan
RACP: Risk-Aware Contingency Planning with Multi-Modal Predictions
Mustafa, Khaled A., Ornia, Daniel Jarne, Kober, Jens, Alonso-Mora, Javier
For an autonomous vehicle to operate reliably within real-world traffic scenarios, it is imperative to assess the repercussions of its prospective actions by anticipating the uncertain intentions exhibited by other participants in the traffic environment. Driven by the pronounced multi-modal nature of human driving behavior, this paper presents an approach that leverages Bayesian beliefs over the distribution of potential policies of other road users to construct a novel risk-aware probabilistic motion planning framework. In particular, we propose a novel contingency planner that outputs long-term contingent plans conditioned on multiple possible intents for other actors in the traffic scene. The Bayesian belief is incorporated into the optimization cost function to influence the behavior of the short-term plan based on the likelihood of other agents' policies. Furthermore, a probabilistic risk metric is employed to fine-tune the balance between efficiency and robustness. Through a series of closed-loop safety-critical simulated traffic scenarios shared with human-driven vehicles, we demonstrate the practical efficacy of our proposed approach that can handle multi-vehicle scenarios.
Computing Multi-Modal Journey Plans under Uncertainty
Botea, Adi, Kishimoto, Akihiro, Nikolova, Evdokia, Braghin, Stefano, Berlingerio, Michele, Daly, Elizabeth
Multi-modal journey planning, which allows multiple types of transport within a single trip, is becoming increasingly popular, due to a strong practical interest and an increasing availability of data. In real life, transport networks feature uncertainty. Yet, most approaches assume a deterministic environment, making plans more prone to failures such as missed connections and major delays in the arrival. This paper presents an approach to computing optimal contingent plans in multi-modal journey planning. The problem is modeled as a search in an and/or state space. We describe search enhancements used on top of the AO* algorithm. Enhancements include admissible heuristics, multiple types of pruning that preserve the completeness and the optimality, and a hybrid search approach with a deterministic and a nondeterministic search. We demonstrate an NP-hardness result, with the hardness stemming from the dynamically changing distributions of the travel time random variables. We perform a detailed empirical analysis on realistic transport networks from cities such as Montpellier, Rome and Dublin. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of our algorithmic contributions, and the benefits of contingent plans as compared to standard sequential plans, when the arrival and departure times of buses are characterized by uncertainty.
Optimal Limited Contingency Planning
Meuleau, Nicolas, Smith, David
For a given problem, the optimal Markov policy can be considerred as a conditional or contingent plan containing a (potentially large) number of branches. Unfortunately, there are applications where it is desirable to strictly limit the number of decision points and branches in a plan. For example, it may be that plans must later undergo more detailed simulation to verify correctness and safety, or that they must be simple enough to be understood and analyzed by humans. As a result, it may be necessary to limit consideration to plans with only a small number of branches. This raises the question of how one goes about finding optimal plans containing only a limited number of branches. In this paper, we present an any-time algorithm for optimal k-contingency planning (OKP). It is the first optimal algorithm for limited contingency planning that is not an explicit enumeration of possible contingent plans. By modelling the problem as a Partially Observable Markov Decision Process, it implements the Bellman optimality principle and prunes the solution space. We present experimental results of applying this algorithm to some simple test cases.
Planning with State Uncertainty via Contingency Planning and Execution Monitoring
Wang, Minlue (University of Birmingham) | Dearden, Richard (University of Birmingham)
An example is a Mars rover: The major problem with applying POMDP approaches to thanks to low-level control and obstacle avoidance, rovers realistic planning problems like the Mars rovers is the sheer can be expected to reach their destinations reliably, and can size of the problems. Using point-based approximations and collect and communicate data, but they do not know in advance structured representations similar to those used in classical which science targets are interesting and hence will planning (Poupart 2005), problems with tens of millions provide valuable data. Similarly, robots performing tasks of states can be solved approximately, but even that corresponds such as security or cognitive assistance are generally able to to a classical planning problem with only 25 binary navigate reliably, but use unreliable vision algorithms to detect variables, which is a quite small problem by the standards the people and objects with which they are supposed of classical deterministic planning. The alternative we propose to interact. Following Besse and Chaib-draa (2009), we in this paper is to construct a series of classical deterministic will refer to problems with deterministic actions but stochastic planning problems from the quasi-deterministic observations as quasi-deterministic problems, which differ problem. By solving each of these deterministic problems from Deterministic-POMDPs (DET-POMDPS) (Bonet we construct a contingent plan--one that contains branches 2009) by taking into account of uncertainty from observation to be chosen between at run-time.
A Translation-based Approach to Contingent Planning
Albore, Alexandre (Universitat Pompeu Fabra) | Palacios, Héctor (Universidad Simón Bolívar) | Geffner, Héctor (ICREA &)
P. This compilation, however, is linear in the number of possible initial states that is exponential in the number of fluents. The problem of planning in the presence of sensing We show nonetheless that even in such cases, a sound, has been addressed in recent years as a nondeterministic complete, and polynomial translation X(P) is possible, provided search problem in belief space. In this that the problem P has bounded contingent width, and work, we use ideas advanced recently for compiling show that the contingent width of almost all existing benchmarks conformant problems into classical ones for introducing is 1; a result that parallels the one reported by Palacios a different approach where contingent problems and Geffner for conformant planning. We then show how the P are mapped into non-deterministic problems non-deterministic but fully observable problem X(P) can be X(P) in state space.