Magdon-Ismail, Malik
Examining the Use of Neural Networks for Feature Extraction: A Comparative Analysis using Deep Learning, Support Vector Machines, and K-Nearest Neighbor Classifiers
Notley, Stephen, Magdon-Ismail, Malik
Neural networks in many varieties are touted as very powerful machine learning tools because of their ability to distill large amounts of information from different forms of data, extracting complex features and enabling powerful classification abilities. In this study, we use neural networks to extract features from both images and numeric data and use these extracted features as inputs for other machine learning models, namely support vector machines (SVMs) and k-nearest neighbor classifiers (KNNs), in order to see if neural-network-extracted features enhance the capabilities of these models. We tested 7 different neural network architectures in this manner, 4 for images and 3 for numeric data, training each for varying lengths of time and then comparing the results of the neural network independently to those of an SVM and KNN on the data, and finally comparing these results to models of SVM and KNN trained using features extracted via the neural network architecture. This process was repeated on 3 different image datasets and 2 different numeric datasets. The results show that, in many cases, the features extracted using the neural network significantly improve the capabilities of SVMs and KNNs compared to running these algorithms on the raw features, and in some cases also surpass the performance of the neural network alone. This in turn suggests that it may be a reasonable practice to use neural networks as a means to extract features for classification by other machine learning models for some datasets.
Optimal Sparse Linear Encoders and Sparse PCA
Magdon-Ismail, Malik, Boutsidis, Christos
Principal components analysis~(PCA) is the optimal linear encoder of data. Sparse linear encoders (e.g., sparse PCA) produce more interpretable features that can promote better generalization. (\rn{1}) Given a level of sparsity, what is the best approximation to PCA? (\rn{2}) Are there efficient algorithms which can achieve this optimal combinatorial tradeoff? We answer both questions by providing the first polynomial-time algorithms to construct \emph{optimal} sparse linear auto-encoders; additionally, we demonstrate the performance of our algorithms on real data.
Approximating Sparse PCA from Incomplete Data
KUNDU, ABHISEK, Drineas, Petros, Magdon-Ismail, Malik
We study how well one can recover sparse principal componentsof a data matrix using a sketch formed from a few of its elements. We show that for a wide class of optimization problems,if the sketch is close (in the spectral norm) to the original datamatrix, then one can recover a near optimal solution to the optimizationproblem by using the sketch. In particular, we use this approach toobtain sparse principal components and show that for \math{m} data pointsin \math{n} dimensions,\math{O(\epsilon^{-2}\tilde k\max\{m,n\})} elements gives an\math{\epsilon}-additive approximation to the sparse PCA problem(\math{\tilde k} is the stable rank of the data matrix).We demonstrate our algorithms extensivelyon image, text, biological and financial data.The results show that not only are we able to recover the sparse PCAs from the incomplete data, but by using our sparse sketch, the running timedrops by a factor of five or more.
Column Selection via Adaptive Sampling
Paul, Saurabh, Magdon-Ismail, Malik, Drineas, Petros
Selecting a good column (or row) subset of massive data matrices has found many applications in data analysis and machine learning. We propose a new adaptive sampling algorithm that can be used to improve any relative-error column selection algorithm. Our algorithm delivers a tighter theoretical bound on the approximation error which we also demonstrate empirically using two well known relative-error column subset selection algorithms. Our experimental results on synthetic and real-world data show that our algorithm outperforms non-adaptive sampling as well as prior adaptive sampling approaches.
Approximating Sparse PCA from Incomplete Data
Kundu, Abhisek, Drineas, Petros, Magdon-Ismail, Malik
We study how well one can recover sparse principal components of a data matrix using a sketch formed from a few of its elements. We show that for a wide class of optimization problems, if the sketch is close (in the spectral norm) to the original data matrix, then one can recover a near optimal solution to the optimization problem by using the sketch. In particular, we use this approach to obtain sparse principal components and show that for \math{m} data points in \math{n} dimensions, \math{O(\epsilon^{-2}\tilde k\max\{m,n\})} elements gives an \math{\epsilon}-additive approximation to the sparse PCA problem (\math{\tilde k} is the stable rank of the data matrix). We demonstrate our algorithms extensively on image, text, biological and financial data. The results show that not only are we able to recover the sparse PCAs from the incomplete data, but by using our sparse sketch, the running time drops by a factor of five or more.
Recovering PCA from Hybrid-$(\ell_1,\ell_2)$ Sparse Sampling of Data Elements
Kundu, Abhisek, Drineas, Petros, Magdon-Ismail, Malik
This paper addresses how well we can recover a data matrix when only given a few of its elements. We present a randomized algorithm that element-wise sparsifies the data, retaining only a few its elements. Our new algorithm independently samples the data using sampling probabilities that depend on both the squares ($\ell_2$ sampling) and absolute values ($\ell_1$ sampling) of the entries. We prove that the hybrid algorithm recovers a near-PCA reconstruction of the data from a sublinear sample-size: hybrid-($\ell_1,\ell_2$) inherits the $\ell_2$-ability to sample the important elements as well as the regularization properties of $\ell_1$ sampling, and gives strictly better performance than either $\ell_1$ or $\ell_2$ on their own. We also give a one-pass version of our algorithm and show experiments to corroborate the theory.
Optimal Sparse Linear Auto-Encoders and Sparse PCA
Magdon-Ismail, Malik, Boutsidis, Christos
Principal components analysis (PCA) is the optimal linear auto-encoder of data, and it is often used to construct features. Enforcing sparsity on the principal components can promote better generalization, while improving the interpretability of the features. We study the problem of constructing optimal sparse linear auto-encoders. Two natural questions in such a setting are: i) Given a level of sparsity, what is the best approximation to PCA that can be achieved? ii) Are there low-order polynomial-time algorithms which can asymptotically achieve this optimal tradeoff between the sparsity and the approximation quality? In this work, we answer both questions by giving efficient low-order polynomial-time algorithms for constructing asymptotically \emph{optimal} linear auto-encoders (in particular, sparse features with near-PCA reconstruction error) and demonstrate the performance of our algorithms on real data.
NP-Hardness and Inapproximability of Sparse PCA
Magdon-Ismail, Malik
Feature Selection for Linear SVM with Provable Guarantees
Paul, Saurabh, Magdon-Ismail, Malik, Drineas, Petros
We give two provably accurate feature-selection techniques for the linear SVM. The algorithms run in deterministic and randomized time respectively. Our algorithms can be used in an unsupervised or supervised setting. The supervised approach is based on sampling features from support vectors. We prove that the margin in the feature space is preserved to within $\epsilon$-relative error of the margin in the full feature space in the worst-case. In the unsupervised setting, we also provide worst-case guarantees of the radius of the minimum enclosing ball, thereby ensuring comparable generalization as in the full feature space and resolving an open problem posed in Dasgupta et al. We present extensive experiments on real-world datasets to support our theory and to demonstrate that our method is competitive and often better than prior state-of-the-art, for which there are no known provable guarantees.
Random Projections for Linear Support Vector Machines
Paul, Saurabh, Boutsidis, Christos, Magdon-Ismail, Malik, Drineas, Petros
Let X be a data matrix of rank \rho, whose rows represent n points in d-dimensional space. The linear support vector machine constructs a hyperplane separator that maximizes the 1-norm soft margin. We develop a new oblivious dimension reduction technique which is precomputed and can be applied to any input matrix X. We prove that, with high probability, the margin and minimum enclosing ball in the feature space are preserved to within \epsilon-relative error, ensuring comparable generalization as in the original space in the case of classification. For regression, we show that the margin is preserved to \epsilon-relative error with high probability. We present extensive experiments with real and synthetic data to support our theory.