Reviews: Distributionally Robust Optimization and Generalization in Kernel Methods

I raised my score from 4 to 6 after reading the author's feedback, mainly due to the novelty of the framework. However, I would expect the author can provide a thorough discussion of the limitation of the result in the camera-ready version. Weakness: Due to the intractbility of the MMD DRO problem, the submission did not find an exact reformulation as much other literature in DRO did for other probability metrics. Instead, the author provides several layers of approximation. The reason why I emphasize the importance of a tight bound, if not an exact reformulation, is that one of the major criticism about (distributionally) robust optimization is that it is sometimes too conservative, and thus a loose upper bound might not be sufficient to mitigate the over-conservativeness and demonstrate the power of distributionally robust optimization. When a new distance is introduced into the DRO framework, a natural question is why it should be used compared with other existing approaches.