Reviews: Zero-Shot Semantic Segmentation

Neural Information Processing Systems 

Writing ---------- The paper is well written and well positioned wrt previous work, overall. However, the main technical core of the paper is only about 1.5 pages long. It would have been better imho to have less detailed results tables and reuse that space for explaining the technique in greater detail. Novelty ---------- While I agree that this paper is the first to address zero-shot semantic segmentation, there have been many papers on zero-shot image classification, abd also some papers on zero-shot object class detection. Importantly, the technique proposed is a direct adaptation of [7], a previous technique for zero-shot image classification.