Reviews: Memory-oriented Decoder for Light Field Salient Object Detection

Neural Information Processing Systems 

My concerns were answered in the rebuttal and I do not see any major concerns in the other reviews. The provided explanations and results should be integrated into the final version. Thus, one could evaluate how much the LSTM module contributes by repeating the RGB input-frame 12 times. This way the model architecture is identical to the 4D version but the input data is only 2D. A direct comparison would then be possible.