Review for NeurIPS paper: UnModNet: Learning to Unwrap a Modulo Image for High Dynamic Range Imaging

The submission has received two positive and two negative reviews. The post-rebuttal discussion has not lead to convergence, and the opinion of the reviewers remain split. The concerns of the "negative" reviewers are: 1) The application is too niche (R1). However, the topic of the paper falls into NeurIPS call for papers, as it is related to low-level computer vision, compressed sensing, deep neural architectures. The authors rebut that the results in [55] were cherry-picked and that they use the code from [55], while fixing the parameters.