Review for NeurIPS paper: Compositional Zero-Shot Learning via Fine-Grained Dense Feature Composition

Neural Information Processing Systems 

Summary and Contributions: --- Update after rebuttal --- I thank the author for their detailed rebuttal and effort to clarify the content of the paper and provide missing details. Authors have addressed most pressing concerns, and it is my opinion that their work could be of interest to the community. I would strongly recommend, however, that authors revise the presentation of their manuscript, in particular with respect to clarity/missing details and claims. Please revise/refine the use of certain terms (cf claims about generative models/self-training, see correctness section) and add all the clarifications provided in the rebuttal (in particular with regards to experimental details not provided in the main paper). The method uses the dense attribute attention method of [10] (DAZLE) to learn a set of attribute specific feature vectors, and subsequently train a classification model by iteratively updating classifier (learning from seen and generated unseen feature) and generating new unseen features using classification predictions.