Reviews: MacNet: Transferring Knowledge from Machine Comprehension to Sequence-to-Sequence Models

Update after Author Feedback: After reading all the reviews and the author feedback, I have two overall comments. The paper is branded as a transfer learning paper, but I'm left disappointed in this respect. I find it very surprising that the attention can be transferred at all, but it is such a small contribution to the MacNet Architecture's overall improvements, that it seems a hard sell. Focal losses have been used before and encoders have been transferred before, but they also contribute to performance improvements... Second comment: the ablations on summarization are necessary for a camera-ready version -- that seems like a hole right now, so I hope they are included in future versions. Overall, I'm still a 6 because you find a combination of things (with some surprising novelty) that improve performance, and it has shown that I should experiment with those things in the future.