Review for NeurIPS paper: Online Decision Based Visual Tracking via Reinforcement Learning

The initial scores were 3478. In the response, authors provide experiment results fusing SOTA trackers on the larger datasets, compared with SOTA trackers, showing improved performance. Authors also provide ablation study using hand-designed rules. During discussion, R2 was satisfied with the new comparisons with SOTA and larger datasets, but was not convinced that the fusion method was useful since there was no ablation study comparing only fusion methods (while keeping trackers the same). R3 was mostly satisfied with the response, but novelty concern was not addressed fully.