Hierarchical Demonstration Order Optimization for Many-shot In-Context Learning

In-Context Learning (ICL) is a technique where large language models (LLMs) leverage multiple demonstrations (i.e., examples) to perform tasks. With the recent expansion of LLM context windows, many-shot ICL (generally with more than 50 demonstrations) can lead to significant performance improvements on a variety of language tasks such as text classification and question answering. Nevertheless, ICL faces the issue of demonstration order instability (ICL-DOI), which means that performance varies significantly depending on the order of demonstrations. Moreover, ICL-DOI persists in many-shot ICL, validated by our thorough experimental investigation. Current strategies for handling ICL-DOI are not applicable to many-shot ICL due to two critical challenges: (1) Most existing methods assess demonstration order quality by first prompting the LLM, then using heuristic metrics based on the LLM's predictions.