Review for NeurIPS paper: Attribute Prototype Network for Zero-Shot Learning

Neural Information Processing Systems 

The authors satisfactorily addressed the concerns of the reviewers regarding novelty, comparisons to related work, and visualizations of mixed-attribute localization. As such, it is felt that this paper would be a good contribution to the ZSL field. Please incorporate the exposition, clarifications, and additional experiments from the rebuttal into the main text.