Review for NeurIPS paper: Steering Distortions to Preserve Classes and Neighbors in Supervised Dimensionality Reduction

Weaknesses: I have the following critical concerns about this paper: 1. The used datasets are too simple. More complex datasets such as SculptFaces in NeRV paper are required to evaluate the performance of the proposed algorithm. As detailed above, ClassNeRV could be seen as a variation of NeRV through penalizing within-class missed neighbors and between-class false neighbors with class information. Therefore, in my opinion, it is not a significant contribution. According to Sec 3.2, they derived the ClassNeRV Stress Function from NeRV Stress Function by splitting Eq. 2 into within-class and between-class relations.